HomeMy WebLinkAboutPermit PL12-008 - CITY OF TUKWILA - SIGN CODE AMENDMENTSIGN CODE AMENDMENTS
CITY WIDE
P L 1 2-008
L 12-009
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT
COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE PLAN AMENDMENT
SiATi= CD ViA3C-1KC-TON
16" d Fikaran &r"eel '-;i= - PO Bor 4252fi5 fa Ofy";iep a.'AVasF?i17q:r'n 9v.'S0 252 i60)2i-dG0
° (3'7
y^5'via' griv
May 22, 2012
Brandon Miles
Assistant Planner
City of Tukwila
6200 Southcenter Boulevard
Tukwila, Washington 98188
Dear Mr. Miles:
Thank you for sending the Washington State Department of Commerce (Commerce) the following materials as
required under RCW 36.70A.106. Please keep this letter as documentation that you have met this procedural
requirement.
City of Tukwila - Adopted Ordinance No. 2375, minor amendments to the Tukwila municipal code
relating to signs. These materials were received on May 22, 2012 and processed with the Material ID #
18107.
We have forwarded a copy of this notice to other state agencies.
If this submitted material is an adopted amendment, then please keep this letter as documentation that you
have met the procedural requirement under RCW 36.70A.106.
If you have submitted this material as a draft amendment, then final adoption may occur no earlier than sixty
days following the date of receipt by Commerce. Please remember to submit the final adopted amendment
to Commerce within ten days of adoption.
If you have any questions, please contact Growth Management Services at reviewteam@commerce.wa.gov,
or call Dave Andersen (509) 434-4491 or Paul Johnson (360) 725-3048.
Sincerely,
Review Team
Growth Management Services
City of Tukwila
Washington
Ordinance No. ;;3�
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
TUKWILA, WASHINGTON, UPDATING AND EXPANDING THE
SIGN CODE, AS CODIFIED IN TUKWILA MUNICIPAL CODE
TITLE 19, TO RESPOND TO THE NEEDS OF BUSINESSES AND
TO ADDRESS THE CHANGING URBAN LANDSCAPE OF THE
CITY; AMENDING ORDINANCE NO. 2303; PROVIDING FOR
SEVERABILITY; AND ESTABLISHING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Tukwila recognizes that signs are an
important component of the built environment and assist in way -finding, advertising and
personal expression for Tukwila businesses, property owners and residents; and
WHEREAS, regulation of signage is needed in order to preserve and protect the
public welfare, preserve and enhance the appearance of the built environment, control
visual clutter, protect private and public property, and ensure the orderly movement of
motorized and non -motorized forms of transportation; and
WHEREAS, on August 16, 2010, the Tukwila City Council adopted a new,
comprehensive Sign Code for the City of Tukwila, which is codified in Title 19 of the
Tukwila Municipal Code; and
WHEREAS, the Tukwila City Council desires to regularly update the City's
regulations regarding signage in order to respond to the needs of Tukwila businesses
and to address the ongoing changing urban landscape of the City; and
WHEREAS, on April 2, 2012, as required by the Growth Management Act, the City
filed notice with the Washington State Department of Commerce that the City intended
to adopt revisions to the Sign Code; and
WHEREAS, on May 8, 2012, the Director of Community Development determined
that the proposed amendments to Title 19 do not have a probable significant adverse
impact on the environment and issued a Determination of Non -Significance; and
WHEREAS, on May 14, 2012, following public notice, the City Council held a public
hearing to receive testimony regarding the new Sign Code;
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 5-16-12
BM:bjs Page 1 of 12
NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF TUKWILA,
WASHINGTON, HEREBY ORDAINS AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1. Definition of "Billboard Receiving Areas" Amended. Ordinance No.
2303 §2 (part), as codified in Tukwila Municipal Code (TMC) Chapter 19.08,
"Definitions," is hereby amended to read as follows:
Billboard Receiving Areas are those areas of the City along South 180th Street zoned
as Commercial/Light Industrial; those properties south of South 180th Street along West
Valley Highway zoned as Commercial/Light Industrial; all properties located along
Boeing Access Road; those properties along East Marginal Way, north of Boeing
Access Road; and all properties located along Airport Way, north of Boeing Access
Road, for which permits for new billboards may be issued if the criteria of this title are
satisfied. Attachments A and B, codified in Title 19 as Figures 19-1 and 19-2, are
hereby amended. These maps show the billboard receiving areas listed with this
definition and are for illustrative purposes only.
Section 2. TMC Section Adopted. A new section is hereby added to TMC
Chapter 19.08, "Definitions," to read as follows:
GBCI means the Green Building Certification Institute or successor entity.
Section 3. TMC Section Adopted. A new section is hereby added to TMC
Chapter 19.08, "Definitions," to read as follows:
Fuel Canopy is a structure designed to provide weather protection to motorists in order
for them to fill vehicles with gasoline, diesel, compressed natural gas, propane,
electricity or other similar compounds that allow for the powering of vehicles. The
following components must be in place beneath the structure in order for this definition
to apply to a structure: 1) There must be at least two fuel dispensing devices; and 2)
Customers must have the ability to pay electronically.
Section 4. TMC Section Adopted. A new section is hereby added to TMC
Chapter 19.08, "Definitions," to read as follows:
LEED means the Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design or successor
program, as administered by the United States Green Building Council or successor
agency.
Section 5. TMC Section 19.12.030, "Exceptions - Sign Permits Not Required,"
Amended. Ordinance No. 2303 §3 (part), as codified at TMC Section 19.12.030, is
hereby amended to read as follows:
The following shall not require issuance of permits by the City. The exception is
only from the need to obtain a permit and shall not be construed as relief from
compliance with other requirements of this title. The provisions of this section shall be
narrowly construed so as to effectuate the purposes of this title, as enumerated in TMC
Section 19.04.020.
W:1Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 5-16-12
BM:bjs Page 2 of 12
1. Repainting of an existing sign when there is no other alteration. This
exception shall not be interpreted to allow the changing of copy or face changes on an
existing sign.
2. Refacing, panel change or copy change on existing conforming, monument
signs that have valid Tukwila sign permits as permitted by TMC Sections 19.20.030
(13)(7), 19.20.040 (6), or 19.32.075.
3. Temporary signs and decorations customary for holidays, such as
Independence Day and Thanksgiving, erected on private property. Signs may only
contain non-commercial speech.
4. Temporary window signs, subject to the limitations of TMC Section
19.24, 080.
5. Traffic signs and/or markings installed by the City of Tukwila, King County
or Washington State Department of Transportation for the purpose of regulating,
warning or directing traffic. Signs may be installed within the right-of-way or on private
property, with the permission of the property owner. All signs installed under this
exception shall meet the requirements of the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices
for Streets and Highways, current edition, published by the U.S. Department of
Transportation.
6. Signs typically installed on utilities and wireless communication facilities
denoting danger or other safety information, including emergency contact information.
7. Political campaign signs, subject to the limitations of TMC Section
19.24.090.
8. Temporary signs installed at City parks. All signs shall be approved by the
Tukwila Director of Parks and Recreation and shall meet the requirements of this code.
9. Land use notice boards per TMC Section 18.104.110.
10. Text or graphics on umbrellas located in outdoor seating or plaza areas.
11. Up to four directional signs per premises where there is a need to direct
vehicular traffic. Freestanding signs may be up to three feet in height and two square
feet per face or a total of four square feet for all faces. Flush -mounted building signs
may be up to three square feet in size.
12. The following exceptions are specific to properties developed with
residential uses in residential zones:
a. Each residential property shall be permitted one 1.5-square-foot,
building- mounted plaque; and
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 5-16-12
BM:bis Page 3 of 12
b. Each residential property shall be permitted one 6-square-foot banner
or rigid sign that is temporary in nature; and
c. Temporary incidental signs may be displayed with no restrictions from
sunset on a Friday (or the day preceding a designated holiday) until sunset on the
following Sunday (or the Monday following a Sunday if the Monday is a designated
holiday). No individual sign may exceed six square feet in size. It is intended that this
subsection shall apply to garage sale and real estate "open house" signs, however
content of the sign is not restricted.
13. Display of up to three flags, each on individual flag poles, per premise.
Content of the flags is not regulated.
Section 6. TMC Section 19.20.030, "Permanent Signs in Residential Zones,"
Amended. Ordinance No. 2303 §5 (part), as codified at TMC Section 19.20.030,
subparagraph B., is hereby amended to read as follows:
B. Monument Sign Design Standards.
1. The area of a monument sign is limited to 30 square feet per sign face and
a total of 60 square feet for all sides. Monument signs located on a premise with at
least one building that is certified as LEED by the GBCI shall be permitted to be 35
square feet per face and a total of 70 square feet for all sides.
2. The sign shall be no taller than five feet.
3. Maximum width of the sign shall not exceed 15 feet.
4. The sign must meet sight distance triangle restrictions.
5. The sign shall be located in a landscaped. area.
6. The sign may only use indirect down lighting methods except for dynamic
signs as allowed under TMC 1.9.20.030 (D). The lighting shall have no spillover impact
on adjacent properties.
7. A monument sign permitted under this section is permitted to complete
refaces, panel changes and copy changes without the need to obtain a new permit,
provided ALL of the following criteria are met:
a. The monument sign was authorized by the City under a permit issued
on or after August 24, 2010.
b. The property owner, or authorized agent of the property owner, was
the applicant to secure the permit as required under this section.
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 5-16-12
BM:bis Page 4 of 12
c. The reface or copy change does not include any structural changes to
the sign that result in a change of sign or message area, modification in sign height,
inclusion of a dynamic sign component, or change in the monument sign's location.
d. Within 30 days of completion of the copy change or reface, the
property owner or authorized agent shall transmit to the City a Notice of Copy Change
Form with a photo of the revised sign face.
Section 7. TMC Section 19.20.040, "Permanent Free -Standing Signage in
Commercial/Industrial Zones," Amended. Ordinance No. 2303 §5 (part), as codified
at TMC Section 19.20.040, is hereby amended to read as follows:
Monument signs are permitted within all commercial and industrial zones, subject to the
following standards:
1. Design Standards. Each premise is permitted to have one free-standing
monument -style sign. Additional monument signs are permitted if the premise contains
over 800 feet of linear frontage on City or quasi -public streets, per Table 1 below.
Table 1 — Design Standards for Permanent Monument
Signs in Commercial and Industrial Zones
Total ROW
of Premise
Allowable Sign
Total Allowable
Maximum
Number of
Message Area
Sign Size
Height
Signs
Less than
36 square feet per
54 square feet per
400 feet
side/72 square
side/108 square
6 feet
One
feet total
feet total
400-599
50 square feet per
70 square feet
feet
side/100 square
per side/140
7 feet
One
feet total
square feet total
600-799
60 square feet per
80 square feet
feet
side/120 square
per side/160
7 feet
One
feet total
square feet total
800-999
66 square feet per
88 square feet
feet
side/132 square
per side/176
8 feet
Two
feet total
square feet total
1,000 feet
72 square feet per
96 square feet
One for every
and over
side/144 square
per side/192
8 feet
400 feet of linear
feet total
square feet total
street frontage.
a. Allowable sign message area is either the face panel of the sign or, for
channel letters or signs painted on seating or retaining walls, that portion of the sign
devoted to the actual message, logo or business name.
b. Total size is the entire area of the sign, including the support structure.
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 5-16-12
SM:bjs Page 5 of 12
c. Monument signs located on a premise with at least one building that is
certified as LEED by the GBCI shall be permitted to have a sign message area increase
and total size area increase of one percent.
2. Special Corner Properties or Properties with Multiple Street Frontages. A
property that borders on more than one public street, but has less than 800 total feet of
linear frontage, is permitted to have one monument sign per street frontage if the
following criteria are met:
a. The property has at least 200 feet of frontage on each public street
where a sign will be placed;
b. Each public street provides direct access to the property; and
c. For each separate street frontage Table 1 shall be used to determine
the design standards for any proposed monument sign.
3. Setback. All monument signs shall be placed at a minimum of five feet from
all property lines. No sign taller than three feet shall be placed within the sight distance
triangle of an access point, unless it can be demonstrated the sign will not pose a safety
issue by reducing visibility.
4. Maximum Width. The maximum permitted width of a monument sign is 15
feet.
5. Address. In order to facilitate emergency response, all new freestanding
signs shall have the address number or address number range of the premise listed on
the structure. The address shall not be counted toward the allowable sign message
area limit. Address numbers must be plainly legible and visible from the street fronting
the property. These numbers shall contrast with their background. Address numbers
shall be Arabic numerals or alphabet letters. Numbers shall be a minimum of four
inches high with a minimum stroke width of 1.5 inches.
6. A monument sign permitted under this section is permitted to complete
refaces and copy changes without having to obtain a new permit, provided ALL of the
following criteria are met:
a. The monument sign was authorized by the City under a permit issued
on or after August 24, 2010.
b. The property owner, or authorized agent of the property owner, was
the applicant to secure the permit as required by TMC Section 19.20.040 (6)(a).
c. The reface or copy change does not include any structural changes to
the sign that result in a change of sign or message area, modification in sign height,
inclusion of a dynamic sign component, or change in the monument sign's location.
W:\Word Process! ng\Ordinances\Sign Code update 5-16-12
BM:bjs Page 6 of 12
d. Within 30 days of completion of the copy change or reface, the
property owner or authorized agent shall transmit to the City a Notice of Copy Change
Form with a photo of the revised sign face.
Section 8. TMC Section 19.20.050, "Permanent Building -Mounted Signs in
Commercial/industrial Zones," Amended. Ordinance No. 2303 §5 (part), as codified
at TMC Section 19.20.050, subparagraph A., is hereby amended to read as follows:
A. Flush -Mounted Building Signs (Wall Signs).
1. Each separate tenant suite with an exterior public entrance is permitted to
have one flush -mounted building sign per exterior public entrance.
2. Buildings where multiple tenants share a common entrance may have one
flush -mounted building sign per exterior public entrance.
3. Wall signs may only be placed within the section of exposed building face
that qualifies for the placement of the building -mounted sign.
4. The area of the wall sign shall be a percentage of the area of exposed
building face where the sign is proposed to be displayed, as calculated per Table 2.
5. Wall signs may not extend above the top of the parapet or eave of the roof
of the wall on which they are located.
Table 2 — Allowable Message Area for Permanent Wall
Signs in Commercial and Industrial Zones
Area (LxH) of Exposed Building
Face (EBF) in Square Feet
Permitted Sign Area
0-500
EBF x .05 or 20 square feet
501-1,500
EBF-500 x .04 + 25 square feet
1,501-3,000
EBF-1,500 x .03 + 65 square feet
3,001-5,000
EBF-3,000 x .02 + 110 square feet
Over 5,000
150 square feet maximum size ermitted
(1) Any flush -mounted (wall) sign affixed to a building certified as LEEQ by the GBCI shall be
permitted an area increase of .5 percent of the permitted sign area from Table 2.
(2) A fuel canopy, as defined in this title, is permitted to install one flush -mounted building sign
(wall sign) on each separate elevation of the fuel canopy structure. The area of the sign
shall not exceed five square feet; illumination of the sign is permitted.
Section 9. TMC Section 19.20.060, "Pole Banners," Amended. Ordinance No.
2303 §5 (part), as codified at TMC Section 19.20.060, is hereby amended to read as
follows:
A. Pole banners are permitted in the Tukwila Urban Center zone and on properties
that contain a Public Recreation Overlay as defined by Title 18 of the Tukwila Municipal
Code.
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 5-16-12
BM:bjs Page 7 of 12
B. Pole banners may only be attached to parking lot light poles on private
property.
C. Banners may have periodic changes in copy without submittal for a new sign
permit.
D. The maximum area per banner is 10 square feet, with a limit of 2 banners per
pole.
E. The lower edge of the banner must be at least 12 feet above grade.
F. Annual renewal of the banner permit is required.
Section 10. TMC Section Adopted. A new section is hereby added to TMC
Chapter 19.32, "Master Sign Program," to read as follows:
19.32.075 Copy and Refaces of Monument and Grand Monument Signs Approved
under this Chapter
A monument sign or grand monument sign permitted under this section is permitted to
complete refaces and copy changes without having to obtain a new permit, provided
ALL of the following criteria are met:
1. The monument sign or grand monument sign was authorized by the City
under a permit issued on or after August 24, 2010.
2. The property owner, or authorized agent of the property owner, was the
applicant to secure the permit as required by TMC Section 19.32.075 (1).
3. The reface or copy change does not include any structural changes to the
sign that result in a change of sign or message area, modification in sign height,
inclusion of a dynamic sign component, or change in the monument or grand monument
sign's location.
4. Within 30 days of completion of the copy change or reface, the property
owner or authorized agent shall transmit to the City a Notice of Copy Change Form with
a photo of the revised sign face.
Section 11. TMC Chapter Adopted. TMC Chapter 19.37, "Non -Conforming Signs
in Annexation Areas," is hereby established to read as follows:
CHAPTER 19.37
Non -Conforming Signs in Annexation Areas
Sections:
19.37.010 Purpose
19.37.020 Definition and Removal of Legally Non -Conforming Permanent Signs
19.37.030 Non -Conforming Sign Permits
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 5-16-12
BM:bjs Page 8 of 12
19.37.040 Non -Conforming Temporary Signs
19.37.050 Additional Signage Prohibited
19.37.010 Purpose
The purpose of this chapter is to establish limits on the use of and requirements for the
removal of non -conforming signs within areas of the City that were annexed after May 1,
2012. Subject to the remaining restrictions of this chapter, non -conforming signs that
were otherwise lawful on the effective date of the annexation may remain subject to the
limitations under this chapter. The provisions of this chapter do not apply to billboards
within annexation areas.
19.37.020 Definition and Removal of Legally Non -Conforming Permanent Signs
A. All permanent signs within annexation areas are considered legally non-
conforming if the sign was erected in conformance with a valid permit, if a permit was
required, and complied with all applicable laws at the time of the sign's installation.
Non -conforming rights are not granted to temporary signs or signs that were in violation
of King County ordinances or regulations of the State of Washington. The burden of
establishing that a sign is non -conforming lies solely with the individual asserting the
claim that a sign is non -conforming.
B. Any monument sign installed within an annexation area that exceeds Sign
Code standards as to sign area, height or setback by 15 percent or less shall be
deemed a conforming sign.
C., Grace Period for Permanent Signs in Annexation Areas. Signs that were
installed within the annexation area prior to the effective date of the City's annexation
and became non -conforming upon annexation in the City, may be issued a non-
conforming sign permit that will allow the signs to remain for 10 years from the effective
date of the annexation. This 10-year period shall be known as the "annexation grace
period."
D. Sign Modifications During the Annexation Grace Period. During the annexation
grace period, signs with non -conforming sign permits may be refaced and the panel or
copy changed, provided the area, height and location of the sign remain unchanged. A
non -conforming sign permit will be issued for work covered under this section.
Permanent signs and sign structures that are moved, replaced or structurally altered
must be brought into conformance with the current Sign Code regulations.
E. Sign Modifications After the Annexation Grace Period. After the annexation
grace period, the sign is permitted to remain as -is indefinitely. However, relocation, re -
erection, alteration, replacement or change in any way to a legal, non -conforming sign,
including the structure or sign panel/face/copy, will require the sign be brought into
compliance with the sign code in effect at the time of submittal of a complete sign permit
application.
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 5-16-12
SM:bjs Page 9 of 12
19.37.030 Non -Conforming Sign Permits
A. Non -Conforming Sign Inventory. The Director shall, as soon as practicable
after the effective date of the annexation, survey the annexation area for signs that do
not conform to the requirements of Title 19. Upon determination that a sign is non-
conforming or illegal, the Director shall use reasonable efforts to notify the sign owner,
in writing and, where practicable, the owner of the property on which the sign is located.
Notification shall include:
1. Whether the sign is non -conforming or illegal.
2. Whether the sign may be eligible for a non -conforming sign permit. If the
identity of the sign owner cannot be determined after reasonable inquiry, the notice may
be affixed in a conspicuous place on the sign or on the business premises with which
the sign is associated. The failure of the City to identify the sign owner shall not relieve
the property owner from the requirements of this section.
B. Non -Conforming Sign Permits.
1. Eligibility. A non -conforming sign permit may be issued only in accordance
with the standards listed in this chapter.
2. Permit Required. A non -conforming sign permit is required for all eligible
non -conforming signs within the annexation areas. The sign owner shall obtain the
permit within 180 days of notification by the City. Sign permits shall be obtained for any
panel or copy change allowed during the annexation grace period. There is no permit
fee for the issuance of the non -conforming sign permit.
3. Applications. Applications for a non -conforming sign permit shall contain
the name and address of the sign user, the sign owner and the owner of the property
upon which the sign is located, and such other pertinent information as the Director may
require to ensure compliance with this chapter. The Director may waive specific
submittal requirements determined to be unnecessary for review of an application.
4. Failure to Respond. It is the sign owner and/or property owner's
responsibility to return the non -conforming sign permit to the City within the 180 days of
notice as outlined in this section. Failure to respond will constitute a waiver of any
grace period provided to the sign under this chapter and modifications to the sign will be
controlled by TMC Section 19.36.030.
5. Permit Issuance. Any person submitting an application for a non-
conforming sign permit shall use the forms provided by the Department. The Director
shall issue non -conforming sign permits upon a determination of eligibility. The Director
may require the filing of plans or other pertinent information where such information is
necessary to determine compliance with this chapter. Appeals shall be filed in
accordance with TMC Section 19.12.120.
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 5-16-12
BM:bjs Page 10 of 12
C. Loss of Legal Non -conforming Status. Non -conforming signs shall be brought
into compliance with this chapter upon the occurrence of one or more of the following
events:
1. When an application is submitted to the City for a project that is subject to
design review, any non -conforming building -mounted signs on the premise affected by
the construction and all non -conforming free-standing signs lose their non -conforming
status.
2. When any panel or copy changes are proposed after the expiration of the
annexation grace period.
3. When the sign meets the definition of abandoned.
4. Damage of 25 percent or more in the value of either the non -conforming
sign or the structure to which it is affixed.
D. Maintenance. Ordinary maintenance and repair of a sign shall be permitted
without loss of non -conforming status if the cost of all maintenance and repair over a
two-year period is less than 25 percent of the cost of replacing the sign.
19.37.040 Non -Conforming Temporary Signs
A. Non -conforming temporary signs in annexation areas must be removed within
120 days of the effective date of the annexation.
B. Commercial real estate signs in existence in the annexation area prior to the
adoption of this code are permitted to remain for up to three months, after which time
the signs must be removed and any future signage must comply with the terms of this
code.
19.37.050 Additional Signage Prohibited
No additional permanent building -mounted signage is permitted on a tenant space that
contains a non -conforming sign. No additional permanent freestanding signs are
permitted on a premises that contains a non -conforming freestanding sign.
Section 12. Corrections by City Clerk or Code Reviser. Upon approval of the
City Attorney, the City Clerk and the code reviser are authorized to make necessary
corrections to the ordinance, including correction of clerical errors; references to other
local, state or federal laws, codes rules, or regulations; or ordinance numbering and
section/subsection numbering.
Section 13. Severability. If any section, subsection, paragraph, sentence, clause
or phrase of this ordinance or its application to any person or situation should be held to
be invalid or unconstitutional for any reason by a court of competent jurisdiction, such
invalidity or unconstitutionality shall not affect the validity or constitutionality of the
remaining portions of this ordinance or its application to any other person or situation.
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 5-16-12
BM:bjs Page 11 of 12
Section 14. Effective Date. This ordinance or a summary thereof shall be
published in the official newspaper of the City, and shall take effect and be in full force
five days after passage and publication as provided by law.
PASSED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF TUKWILA, WASHINGTON, at
a Regular Meeting thereof this day of , 2012.
ATTEST/AUTHENTICATED:
Christy O'Flahe , MMC, City Clerkv
APPR? D A TO FORM BY:
Filed with the City Clerk:
Passed by the City Council-.
Published:
Effective Date: — -
Ordinance Number: `
Attachments: A - Map of Billboard Receiving Area (West Valley Hwy.)
B - Map of Billboard Receiving Area (Boeing Access Road and
East Marginal Way South)
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 5-16-12
BM:bjs Page 12 of 12
For Illustrative Purposes Only Attachment A
City of Tukwila
TV Billboard
w Receiving
.. Area -�-
`•':gip: CEO N
ig
s� Isis.
80 S
Dr
-
5v
i
City of Tukwila Public Notice of Ordinance Adoption for Ordinances 2375-2377.
On May 21, 2012 the City Council of the City of Tukwila, Washington, adopted the
following ordinances, the main points of which are summarized by title as follows:
Ordinance 2375: AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
TUKWILA, WASHINGTON, UPDATING AND EXPANDING THE SIGN CODE, AS
CODIFIED IN TUKWILA MUNICIPAL CODE TITLE 19, TO RESPOND TO THE NEEDS
OF BUSINESSES AND TO ADDRESS THE CHANGING URBAN LANDSCAPE OF THE
CITY; AMENDING ORDINANCE NO. 2303; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; AND
ESTABLISHING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
Ordinance 2376: AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
TUKWILA, WASHINGTON, AUTHORIZING AND PROVIDING FOR THE ACQUISITION
OF INTERESTS IN LAND FOR THE PURPOSE OF COMPLETING THE TUKWILA
TRANSIT CENTER PROJECT; PROVIDING FOR CONDEMNATION,
APPROPRIATION, TAKING OF LAND AND PROPERTY RIGHTS NECESSARY
THEREFORE; PROVIDING FOR PAYMENT THEREOF; AND DIRECTING THE
INITIATION OF APPROPRIATE PROCEEDINGS IN THE MANNER PROVIDED BY
LAW FOR SAID CONDEMNATION; REPEALING ORDINANCE NO. 2364; PROVIDING
FOR SEVERABILITY; AND ESTABLISHING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
Ordinance 2377: AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
TUKWILA, WASHINGTON, AUTHORIZING AND PROVIDING FOR THE
ACQUISITION OF INTERESTS IN LAND FOR THE PURPOSE OF COMPLETING
THE ANDOVER PARK WEST WIDENING PROJECT; PROVIDING FOR
CONDEMNATION, APPROPRIATION, TAKING OF LAND AND PROPERTY
RIGHTS NECESSARY THEREFORE; PROVIDING FOR PAYMENT THEREOF;
AND DIRECTING THE INITIATION OF APPROPRIATE PROCEEDINGS IN THE
MANNER PROVIDED BY LAW FOR SAID CONDEMNATION; PROVIDING FOR
SEVERABILITY; AND ESTABLISHING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
The full text of these ordinances will be provided upon request.
Christy O'Flaherty, MMC, City Clerk
Published Seattle Times: May 24, 2012
City of Tukwila
Department of Community Development
Jim Haggerton, Mayor
DETERMINATION OF NON -SIGNIFICANCE (DNS) ADDENDUM
Description of Original Proposal:
Jack Pace, Director
In August of 2010, the City Council adopted a new Title 19 of the Tukwila Municipal Code, commonly
referred to as the "Sign Code." Prior the City Council's adoption, the SEPA Responsible Official issued a
Determination of Non -Significance (DNS) on March 12, 2010.
The new Title 19 replaced the City's previous sign code, which had been in place for almost 30-years. A
wide range of signs were permitted under the new sign code. The SEPA Responsible Official reviewed a
SEPA Checklist and staff report on the impacts of the new sign code before issuing the DNS.
For the last two years, City staff has been administering the new sign code and through this
administration, has realized that there were some oversights in the new sign code. To address the issues
that have been identified over the last two years, the City Council is considering minor amendments to the
Sign Code.
These minor amendments include:
1. Allowing small signs on fuel canopies;
2. Streamlining the Permit Process for certain freestanding signs;
3. Providing a fee discount for sign permits that are submitted electronically;
4. Expand the north billboard receiving area to include Airport Way;
5. Allowing Pole Banners in public recreation overlay zones;
6. Providing a sign area increase for LEED certified buildings; and
7. Minor edits to the adopted code to add clarification and to correct scribner's errors.
The SEPA Responsible Official concluded that additional environmental review is not needed for the
proposed amendments and that proposed, minor amendments are consistent with the original SEPA
checklist that was reviewed by the City in March of 2010.
Proponent: City of Tukwila
Location of Proposal: Citywide
Lead Agency: City Of Tukwila
File Number: E10-008
6300 Southcenter Boulevard, Suite #100 - Tukwila, Washington 98188 - Phone 206-431-3670 - Fax 206-431-3665
City of Tukwila
Jim Haggerton, Mayor
INFORMATIONAL MEMORANDUM
TO:
Mayor Haggerton
Community Affairs and Parks Committee
FROM:
Jack Pace, DCD Director
BY:
Brandon J. Miles, Senior Planner
DATE:
April 11, 2012
REVISED ON MAY 1, 2012
SUBJECT:
Amendments to Title 19, "Sign Code"
REVISED AFTER CAP MEETING
13*11L
Should amendments be made to Title 19 of the Tukwila Municipal Code (TMC), commonly
referred to as the "Sign Code?"
BACKGROUND/DISCUSSION
On March 26, 2012, staff presented a memo to Community Affairs and Parks (CAP) dated
March 19, 2012 that outlined nine proposed amendments to the City's Sign Code. A copy of
that memo, the meeting minutes, a proposed Ordinance in strikeout/underlined format and a
proposed draft fee resolution are attached. Generally, CAP was supportive of the proposed
amendments, but required some clarification and additional discussion.
NOTE: In this memo, staff has also added an item regarding non -conforming signs. The issue
of non -conforming signs was not discussed at the March 26`" meeting, but staff would like to
propose a change to certain non -conforming regulations. See below for more information.
1. Commercial Signage on Fuel Canopies
CAP was supportive of this proposed code change, but requested that DCD staff add a
definition for fuel canopy. At the CAP meeting there was some concern that without a clear
definition canopies throughout the City would be eligible for signage. DCD staff proposes the
following definition:
Fuel Canopy is a structure designed to provide weather protection to motorists in order for them
to fill vehicles with: gasoline, diesel, compressed natural gas, propane, electricity or other similar
compounds which allow for the powering of vehicles. The following components must be in
place beneath the structure in order for this definition to apply to a structure, 1) There must be at
least two fuel dispensing devices; and 2) Customers must have the ability to pay electronically
beneath the structure.
The above definition would allow all traditional gas stations to install signage on fuel canopies --
as well as alternative fuel stations, such as the new Blue Star Gas Propane business.
Staff proposes that a fuel canopy be permitted to have one illuminated or non -illuminated sign
for each elevation, with the sign being permitted to be no more than five square feet.
3
INFORMATIONAL MEMO
Page 2
2. Streamline Permit Process for Conforming Freestanding Signs
CAP was supportive of this proposal. New language was added to TMC 19.12.030 "Exceptions -
Sign Permits Not Required," which states that permits are not required for copy changes and
refaces if the work complies with the requirements of TMC 19.20 (Permanent Signs) or 19.32
(Master Sign Program). The language in TMC 19.20 and 19.32 is identical and states the
following:
A monument sign permitted under this section is permitted to complete refaces, panel
changes and copy changes without the need to obtain a new permit, provided ALL of the
following criteria are met:
a. The monument sign was authorized by the City under a permit issued on or after
August 24, 2010.
b. The property owner, or authorized agent of the property owner, was the applicant to
secure the permit as required under this section.
c. As part of the reface and copy change, there can be no structural changes to the
sign which result in a change of sign or message areas; modification in sign height;
inclusion of a dynamic sign component, or change in the monument sign's location.
d. That within 30-days of completion of the copy change or reface, the property owner
or authorized agent shall transmit to the City a Notice of Copy Change form with a
photo of the revised sign face.
3. Electronic Plan Submittal
CAP was supportive of this proposal. The draft resolution reduces permit fees by $50 for
applications for permanent signs that are submitted electronically.
4. Annexation Areas
Staff proposed providing existing signs within annexation areas a ten year grace period that
would commence upon the effective date of the annexation. CAP was supportive of this
proposal. Anew chapter to Title 19 is being proposed; see Section 19.37 of the draft
Ordinance. The Chapter will be TMC 19.37 and will be called "Non -Conforming Signs in
Annexation Areas." The language of this Chapter is nearly identical to the language found in
TMC 19.36 (Non -Conforming Provisions), except that language is inserted to refer to the
effective date of annexation and not the effective date of the original sign Ordinance.
5. Add Airport Way as a Billboard Receiving Area
Staff brought up a concern with the fact that Airport Way was not included in the definition of
"billboard receiving area," provided in TMC 19.08.067. Staff proposed to add Airport Way to the
areas of the City eligible for new billboards, and CAP was supportive of the proposal.
Staff proposes the following changes to TMC 19.08.067:
"Billboard Receiving Areas" are those areas of the City along South 180th Street zoned as
Commercial/Light Industrial; those properties south of South 180th Street along West Valley
Highway zoned as Commercial/Light Industrial; all properties located along Boeing Access
Road; those properties along East Marginal Way, north of Boeing Access Road; and all
properties located along Airport Way, north of Boeing Access road, for which
4 Z.-TCD n Clerk's\Brandcn\Sign Code Update\CAP, 2012.04-2&nfoMemo.doc
INFORMATIONAL MEMO
Page 3
permits for new billboards may be issued if the criteria of this Title are satisfied. Attachment D
and E are maps that show the billboard receiving areas listed with this definition. Attachments D
and E are for illustrative purposes only.
6. Pole Banners fee and Expansion of Allowable Zones
DCD staff discussed two specific items regarding pole banner; the first was the fee; and the
second was the issue of expanding the allowable zones where pole banners could be used.
a. Fee. Staff had initially suggested that the fee for pole banners be $25 for the initial fee
and $15 for renewals. CAP expressed interest in ensuring that the pole banner fee was
reflective of other land use and sign permit fees, specifically the temporary sign permit
fee which currently is $97. The attached resolution reflects the pole banner fee being
$97 for the initial application and $50 for renewals.
b. Additional Zones. DCD staff had proposed allowing pole banners in the Neighborhood
Commercial Center (NCC) zone. One of the reasons to allow pole banners in the NCC
zones was so that Tukwila Village would be able to install such signs. CAP did seem not
to have any objections to the proposed change, but there did seem to be some
hesitation in how the pole banners could be used. As staff noted, the City cannot
regulate content of signs, including pole banners. Staff is now proposing that pole
banners not be allowed in the NCC zone. Much of the NCC zone is located on Tukwila
International Boulevard (TIB), and staff is concerned that properties in the area may not
install high quality pole signs --which would hinder the City's ongoing efforts to revitalize
the area.
During the CAP meeting, the Parks Department discussed a possible desire to install
pole banners at Foster Golf Course; currently, the Sign Code prohibits .such signage.
DCD staff would like to propose that areas of the City that are subject to the Public
Recreation Overlay be permitted to install pole banners. This change would allow pole
banners to be installed at all Tukwila Schools, most City parks, the Community Center
and Fort Dent Park.
7. LEED Certification
CAP was supportive of a small sign area bonus for LEED certified buildings. The proposed
Ordinance reflects the recommendation in the March 19, 2012 memo.
8. Add Notes to Billboard Receiving Maps
CAP was supportive of staff's proposal to add a note on two maps in the Code that state that
the maps are for "Illustrative Purposes Only." Staff also added some language in the definition
of "billboard receiving area" to further clarify that the definition will govern in the event of a
conflict between the definition and the maps, see item 5 above.
9. Correct scribner's error in TMC 19.20.050 (4)
CAP had no concerns with fixing the scribner's error identified above.
ZADCD n CleWs\Brandon\Sign Code Update\CAP, 2012.0443VnfoMemo.doc rj
INFORMATIONAL MEMO
Page 4
Update on the Removal of Non -Conforming Siqns
May 1, 2012. CAP was supportive of the current code language regarding the grace period for
non -conforming signs and did not recommend any of the changes to the regulations discussed
below. The Ordinance in the packet has been updated to remove the changes to the non-
conforming section and that language can be found as a separate attachment to this memo.
Staff would also request policy direction from CAP on an issue related to the removal of non-
conforming signs within the City. This issue was not discussed previously.
As CAP is aware, the City strived to lessen the impact of the new code on businesses within the
City. Due to the fact that the City moved to monument only signage, many freestanding signs in
the City became non -conforming upon the effective date of the new sign code. The rights
associated with each individual sign vary based on the degree to which the sign is non-
conforming. TMC 19.36.040 establishes three non -conforming categories:
a. Signs which were non -conforming under the OLD sign code. These signs may
remain indefinitely, but a reface or copy change is not permitted without bringing the
sign into conformance with the City's sign code. In most cases "bringing the sign into
conformance" requires removal of the sign.
b. Signs which became non -conforming with adoption of the new sign code and
obtained non -conforming sign permits. These signs are provided a ten-year grace
period. During the grace period the signs may have refaces and copy changes, with
a permit. After the grace period the sign may remain indefinitely, but a reface or
copy change is not permitted without bringing the sign into conformance.
c. Non -Conforming Freeway Interchange Signs. All freeway interchange signs became
non -conforming under the new sign code. Freeway interchange signs are provided a
five year grace period in which copy changes and refaces are permitted, with a
permit. After the grace period the sign may remain indefinitely, but a reface or copy
change is not permitted without bringing the sign into conformance.
TMC 19.36.040 requires that property and/or sign owners obtain a no -fee, non -conforming sign
permit for any sign on their premise which does not meet the sign code. Property owners
and/or sign owners must have obtained the non -conforming permit within 180-days of being
notified by the City that their signs are non -conforming. Non -conforming rights are lost if the
property owner and/or sign owner failed to submit the non -conforming permit within the 180-day
period (TMC 19.36,040).
The City has sent out a total of 174 notices to property owners and/or sign owners informing
them that their signs are non -conforming. A total 123 response' to the City's notification were
received back. A total of 44 never responded to the City's notification that their signs were non-
conforming and thus under TMC 19.36.040 the signs should be removed.
Staff would like policy direction from the City Council on the following question: Should the City
begin to enforce the provisions of TMC 19.36, requiring that 44 signs be removed within the
City? An advantage of this approach would be that a significant number of non -conforming signs
would be removed and thus improve the City's streetscape and the overall urban environment.
A disadvantage of this approach would be the impact the removal would have on businesses
and property owners who, once receiving the Notice and Order, may approach the City Council
to amend the code requirements.
189 submitted the non -conforming permit; 25 were received by the City and are pending; two went through the
Master Sign Program; and seven used the opt -out language.
6 ZADCD n Clerk's\Brandon\Sign Code Update\CAP, 2012.04-23\InfoMemo.doc
INFORMATIONAL MEMO
Page 5
Staff would like to propose an alternative: Any sign that did not obtain the non -conforming sign
permit, as required, would be permitted to remain indefinitely; however any proposed copy
change or reface would require that the sign be brought up to the provisions of the City's sign
code. This approach would still result in the removal of non -conforming signs, but over a longer
time frame.
FINANCIAL IMPACT
Permit fees will be reduced by not requiring permits for certain refaces and copy changes.
However, permit fees are meant to compensate the City for time reviewing the permit and are
not meant to generate revenue. By waiving certain permits, it will free up staff to work on other
current and long range projects.
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends that the attached Ordinance and Resolution be forward to the May 14tn
Committee of the Whole meeting for a public hearing and discussion by the full Council. Action
on the Ordinance and Resolution is anticipated at the May 21 st Regular Council Meeting.
ATTACHMENTS
• Draft Ordinance;
• Draft Resolution;
• Staff's memo from March 19, 2012; and
• Minutes from April 23, 2012, Community Affairs and Parks Meeting
• Minutes from the March 26, 2012 Community Affairs and Parks Meeting.
• Section of Ordinance Removed by CAP on April 23, 2012
ZADCD n Clerk's\Brandon\Sign Code Update\CAP, 2012.04-2UnfoMemo.doc %
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
TUKWILA, WASHINGTON, UPDATING AND EXPANDING THE
SIGN CODE, AS CODIFIED IN TUKWILA MUNICIPAL CODE
TITLE 19, TO RESPOND TO THE NEEDS OF BUSINESSES AND
TO ADDRESS THE CHANGING URBAN LANDSCAPE OF THE
CITY; AMENDING ORDINANCE NO. 2303; PROVIDING FOR
SEVERABILITY; AND ESTABLISHING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Tukwila recognizes that signs are an
important component of the built environment and assist in way -finding, advertising and
personal expression for Tukwila businesses, property owners and residents; and
WHEREAS, regulation of signage is needed in order to preserve and protect the
public welfare, preserve and enhance the appearance of the built environment, control
visual clutter, protect private and public property, and ensure the orderly movement of
motorized and non -motorized forms of transportation; and
WHEREAS, on August 16, 2010, the Tukwila City Council adopted a new,
comprehensive Sign Code for the City of Tukwila, which is codified in Title 19 of the
Tukwila Municipal Code; and
WHEREAS, the Tukwila City Council desires to regularly update the City's
regulations regarding signage in order to respond to the needs of Tukwila businesses
and to address the ongoing changing urban landscape of the City; and
WHEREAS, on April 2, 2012, as required by the Growth Management Act, the City
filed notice with the Washington State Department of Commerce that the City intended
to adopt revisions to the Sign Code; and
WHEREAS, on May 8, 2012, the Director of Community Development determined
that the proposed amendments to Title 19 do not have a probable significant adverse
impact on the environment and issued a Determination of Non -Significance; and
WHEREAS, on May 14, 2012, following public notice, the City Council held a public
hearing to receive testimony regarding the new Sign Code;
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 5-8-12
BM:bjs Page 1 of 12
9
NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF TUKWILA,
WASHINGTON, HEREBY ORDAINS AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1. Definition of "Billboard Receiving Areas" Amended. Ordinance No.
2303 §2 (part), as codified in Tukwila Municipal Code (TMC) Chapter 19,08,
"Definitions," is hereby amended to read as follows:
Billboard Receiving Areas are those areas of the City along South 180th Street zoned
as Commercial/Light Industrial; those properties south of South 180th Street along West
Valley Highway zoned as Commercial/Light Industrial; all properties located along
Boeing Access Road; an -those properties along East Marginal Way, north of Boeing
Access Road; and all properties located along Airport Way, north of Boeing Access
Road, for which permits for new billboards may be issued if the criteria of this Ghapter
title are satisfied. Attachments AD and €B, codified in Title 19 as Figures 19-1 and 19-
2 are hereby amended. These maps that -show the billboard receiving areas listed with
this definition and are for illustrative purposes only.
Section 2. TMC Section Adopted. A new section is hereby added to TMC
Chapter 19.08, "Definitions," to read as follows:
GBCI means the Green Building Certification Institute or successor entity.
Section 3. TMC Section Adopted. A new section is hereby added to TMC
Chapter 19.08, "Definitions," to read as follows. -
Fuel Canopy is a structure designed to provide weather protection to motorists in order
for them to fill vehicles with gasoline, diesel, compressed natural gas, propane,
electricity or other similar compounds that allow for the powering of vehicles. The
following components must be in place beneath the structure in order for this definition
to apply to a structure: 1) There must be at least two fuel dispensing devices; and 2)
Customers must have the ability to pay electronically.
Section 4. TMC Section Adopted. A new section is hereby added to TMC
Chapter 19.08, "Definitions," to read as follows:
LEED means the Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design or successor
program, as administered by the United States Green Building Council or successor
agency.
Section 5. TMC Section 19.12.030, "Exceptions - Sign Permits Not Required,"
Amended. Ordinance No. 2303 §3 (part), as codified at TMC Section 19.12.030, is
hereby amended to read as follows:
The following shall not require issuance of permits by the City. The exception is
only from the need to obtain a permit and shall not be construed as relief from
compliance with other requirements of this title. The provisions of this section shall be
narrowly construed so as to effectuate the purposes of this title, as enumerated in TMC
Section 19.04.020.
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 5-8-12
BM:bjs Page 2 of 12
10
1. Repainting of an existing sign when there is no other alteration. This
exception shall not be interpreted to allow the changing of copy or face changes on an
existing sign.
2. Refacing, panel change or copy change on existing conforming, monument
signs that have valid Tukwila sign permits as permitted by TMC Sections 19.20.030
(13)(7), 19.20.040 (6), or 19.32.075.
23_Temporary signs and decorations customary for holidays, such as
Independence Day and Thanksgiving, erected on private property. Signs may only
contain non-commercial speech.
34. Temporary window signs, subject to the limitations of TMC Section
19.24.080.
45. Traffic signs and/or markings installed by the City of Tukwila, King County
or Washington State Department of Transportation for the purpose of regulating,
warning or directing traffic_ Signs may be installed within the right-of-way or on private
property, with the permission of the property owner. All signs installed under this
exception shall meet the requirements of the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices
for Streets and Highways, current edition, published by the U.S. Department of
Transportation.
56. Signs typically installed on utilities and wireless communication facilities
denoting danger or other safety information, including emergency contact information.
67. Political campaign signs, subject to the limitations of TMC Section
19.24.090.
78. Temporary signs installed at City parks. All signs shall be approved by the
Tukwila Director of Parks and Recreation and shall meet the requirements of this code.
69. Land use notice boards per TMC Section 18.104.110.
610. Text or graphics on umbrellas located in outdoor seating or plaza
areas.
4511. Up to four directional signs per premises where there is a need to
direct vehicular traffic. Freestanding signs may be up to three feet in height and two
square feet per face or a total of four square feet for all faces. Flush -mounted building
signs may be up to three square feet in size.
4412. The following exceptions are specific to properties developed with
residential uses in residential zones:
a. Each residential property shall be permitted one 1.5-square-foot,
building- mounted plaque; and
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 5-8-12
BM:bjs Page 3 of 12
11
b. Each residential property shall be permitted one 6-square-foot banner
or rigid sign that is temporary in nature; and
c. Temporary incidental signs may be displayed with no restrictions from
sunset on a Friday (or the day preceding a designated holiday) until sunset on the
following Sunday (or the Monday following a Sunday if the Monday is a designated
holiday). No individual sign may exceed six square feet in size. it is intended that this
subsection shall apply to garage sale and real estate "open house" signs, however
content of the sign is not restricted.
4213. Display of up to three flags, each on individual flag poles, per premise.
Content of the flags is not regulated.
Section 6. TMC Section 19.20.030, "Permanent Signs in Residential Zones,"
Amended. Ordinance No. 2303 §5 (part), as codified at TMC Section 19.20.030,
subparagraph B., is hereby amended to read as follows:
B. Monument Sign Design Standards.
1. The area of a monument sign is limited to 30 square feet per sign face and
a total of 60 square feet for all sides. Monument signs located on a premise with at
least one building that is certified as LEED by the GBCI shall be permitted to be 35
square feet per face and a total of 70 square feet for all sides.
2. The sign shall be no taller than five feet.
3. Maximum width of the sign shall not exceed 15 feet.
4. The sign must meet sight distance triangle restrictions.
5. The sign shall be located in a landscaped area.
6. The sign may only use indirect down lighting methods except for dynamic
signs as allowed under TMC 19.20.030 (D). The lighting shall have no spillover impact
on adjacent properties.
7. A monument sign permitted under this section is permitted to complete
refaces, panel changes and copy changes without the need to obtain a new permit,
provided ALL of the following criteria are met:
a. The monument sign was authorized by the City under a permit issued
on or after August 24, 2010.
b. The property owner, or authorized agent of the property owner, was
the applicant to secure the permit as required under this section.
WAWord Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 5-8-12
BM:bjs Page 4 of 12
12
c. The reface or copy change does not include any structural changes to
the sign that result in a change of sign or message area, modification in sign height,
inclusion of a dynamic sign component, or change in the monument sign's location.
d. Within 30 days of completion of the copy change or reface, the
property owner or authorized agent shall transmit to the City a Notice of Copy Change
Form with a photo of the revised sign face.
Section 7. TMC Section 19.20.040, "Permanent Free -Standing Signage in
Commercial/Industrial Zones," Amended. Ordinance No. 2303 §5 (part), as codified
at TMC Section 19.20.040, is hereby amended to read as follows:
Monument signs are permitted within all commercial and industrial zones, subject to the
following standards:
1. Design Standards. Each premise is permitted to have one free-standing
monument -style sign. Additional monument signs are permitted if the premise contains
over 800 feet of linear frontage on City or quasi -public streets, per Table 1 below.
Table 1 — Design Standards for Permanent Monument
Signs in Commercial and Industrial Zones
Total ROW
Allowable Sign
Total Allowable
Maximum
of Premise
Message Area
Sign Size
Height
Number of
Signs
Less than
36 square feet per
54 square feet per
400 feet
side/72 square
side/108 square
6 feet
One
feet total
feet total
400-599
50 square feet per
70 square feet
feet
side/100 square
per side/140
7 feet
One
feet total
square feet total
600-799
60 square feet per
80 square feet
feet
side/120 square
per side/160
7 feet
One
feet total
square feet total
800-999
66 square feet per
88 square feet
feet
side/132 square
per side/176
8 feet
Two
feet total
square feet total
1,000 feet
72 square feet per
96 square feet
One for every
and over
side/144 square
per side/192
8 feet
400 feet of linear
feet total
square feet total
street frontage.
a. Allowable sign message area is either the face panel of the sign or, for
channel letters or signs painted on seating or retaining walls, that portion of the sign
devoted to the actual message, logo or business name.
b. Total size is the entire area of the sign, including the support structure.
WAWord Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 5-8-12
BM:bjs
Page 5 of 12
13
c. Monument signs located on a premise with at least one building that is
certified as LEED by the GBCI shall be permitted to have a sign message area increase
and total size area increase of one percent.
2. Special Comer Properties or Properties with Multiple Street Frontages. A
property that borders on more than one public street, but has less than 800 total feet of
linear frontage, is permitted to have one monument sign per street frontage if the
following criteria are met:
a. The property has at least 200 feet of frontage on each public street
where a sign will be placed;
b. Each public street provides direct access to the property; and
c. For each separate street frontage Table 1 shall be used to determine
the design standards for any proposed monument sign.
3. Setback. All monument signs shall be placed at a minimum of five feet from
all property lines. No sign taller than three feet shall be placed within the sight distance
triangle of an access point, unless it can be demonstrated the sign will not pose a safety
issue by reducing visibility.
4. Maximum Width. The maximum permitted width of a monument sign is 15
feet.
5. Address. In order to facilitate emergency response, all new freestanding
signs shall have the address number or address number range of the premise listed on
the structure. The address shall not be counted toward the allowable sign message
area limit. Address numbers must be plainly legible and visible from the street fronting
the property. These numbers shall contrast with their background. Address numbers
shall be Arabic numerals or alphabet letters. Numbers shall be a minimum of four
inches high with a minimum stroke width of 1.5 inches.
6. A monument sign permitted under this section is permitted to complete
refaces and copy changes without having to obtain a new permit, provided ALL of the
following criteria are met:
a. The monument sign was authorized by the City under a permit issued
on or after August 24, 2010.
b. The property owner, or authorized agent of the property owner, was
the applicant to secure the permit as required by TMC Section 19.20.040 (6)(a).
c. The reface or copy change does not include any structural changes to
the sign that result in a change of sign or message area, modification in sign height
inclusion of a dynamic siqn component, or change in the monument sign's location.
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 5-8-12
BM:bjs Page 6 of 12
14
d. Within 30 days of completion of the copy change or reface, the
property owner or authorized agent shall transmit to the City a Notice of Copy Change
Form with a photo of the revised sign face.
Section 8. TMC Section 19.20.050, "Permanent Building -Mounted Signs in
CommerciallIndustrial Zones," Amended. Ordinance No. 2303 §5 (part), as codified
at TMC Section 19.20.050, subparagraph A., is hereby amended to read as follows:
A. Flush -Mounted Building Signs (Wall Signs).
1. Each separate tenant suite with an exterior public entrance is permitted to
have one flush -mounted building sign per exterior public entrance.
2. Buildings where multiple tenants share a common entrance may have one
flush -mounted building sign per exterior public entrance.
3. Wall signs may only be placed within the section of exposed building face
that qualifies for the placement of the building -mounted sign.
4. The area of the wall sign shall be a percentage of the area of exposed
building face where the sign is proposed to be displayed, as calculated per Table 2.
5. Wall signs may not extend above the top of the parapet or eave of the roof
of the wall on which they are located.
Table 2 - Allowable Message Area for Permanent Wall
Signs in Commercial and Industrial Zones
Area (LxH) of Exposed Building
Face (EBF) in Square Feet
Permitted Sign Area
0-500
EBF x .05 or 20 square feet
501-1,500
EBF-500 x .04 + 25 square feet
1,501-3,000
EBF-1,500 x .03 + 65 square feet
3,001-5,000
EBF-3,000 x .02 + 110 square feet
Over 5,000
150 square feet maximum size permitted
1) Anv flush -mounted (wall) sign affixed to a building certified as LEEQ by the GBCI shall be
permitted an area increase of .5 percent of the permitted sign area from Table 2.
(2) A fuel canopy, as defined in this title, is permitted to install one flush -mounted building sign
(wall sign) on each separate elevation of the fuel canopy structure. The area of the sign
shall not exceed five square feet: illumination of the sign is permitted.
Section 9. TMC Section 19.20.060, "Pole Banners," Amended. Ordinance No.
2303 §5 (part), as codified at TMC Section 19.20.060, is hereby amended to read as
follows:
A. Pole banners are epAy-permitted in the Tukwila Urban Center zone and on
roperties that contain a Public Recreation Overlav as defined by Title 18 of the Tukwila
Municipal Code.
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 5-8-12 v J
BM:bjs Page 7 of 12
15
B. Pole banners may only be attached to parking lot light poles on private
property.
C. Banners may have periodic changes in copy without submittal for a new sign
permit.
D. The maximum area per banner is 10 square feet, with a limit of 2 banners per
pole.
E. The lower edge of the banner must be at least 12 feet above grade.
F. Annual renewal of the banner permit is required.
Section 10. TMC Section Adopted. A new section is hereby added to TMC
Chapter 19.32, "Master Sign Program," to read as follows:
19.32.075 Copy and Refaces of Monument and Grand Monument Signs Approved
under this Chapter
A monument sign or grand monument sign permitted under this section is permitted to
complete refaces and copy changes without having to obtain a new permit, provided
ALL of the following criteria are met:
1. The monument sign or grand monument sign was authorized by the City
under a permit issued on or after August 24, 2010.
2. The property owner, or authorized agent of the property owner, was the
applicant to secure the permit as required by TMC Section 19.32.075 (1).
3. The reface or copy change does not include any structural changes to the
sign that result in a change of sign or message area, modification in sign height,
inclusion of a dynamic sign component, or change in the monument or grand monument
sign's location.
4. Within 30 days of completion of the copy change or reface, the property
owner or authorized agent shall transmit to the City a Notice of Copy Change Form with
a photo of the revised sign face.
Section 11. TMC Chapter Adopted. TMC Chapter 19.37, "Non -Conforming Signs
in Annexation Areas," is hereby established to read as follows:
CHAPTER 19.37
Non -Conforming Signs in Annexation Areas
Sections:
19.37.010 Purpose
19.37.020 Definition and Removal of Legally Non -Conforming Permanent Signs
19.37.030 Non-Conforminq Siqn Permits
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 5-8-12
BM:bjs Page 8 of 12
16
19.37.040 Non -Conforming Temporary Signs
19.37.050 Additional Signage Prohibited
19.37.010 Purpose
The purpose of this chapter is to establish limits on the use of and requirements for the
removal of non -conforming signs within areas of the City that were annexed after May 1,
2012. Subject to the remaining restrictions of this chapter, non -conforming signs that
were otherwise lawful on the effective date of the annexation may remain subiect to the
limitations under this chapter. The provisions of this chapter do not apply to billboards
within annexation areas.
19.37.020 Definition and Removal of Legally Non -Conforming Permanent Signs
A. All permanent signs within annexation areas are considered legally non-
conforming if the sign was erected in conformance with a valid permit, if a permit was
required and complied with all applicable laws at the time of the sign's installation.
Non -conforming rights are not granted to temporary signs or signs that were in violation
of King County ordinances or regulations of the State of Washington. The burden of
establishing that a sign is non -conforming lies solely with the individual asserting the
claim that a sign is non -conforming.
B. Any monument sign installed within an annexation area that exceeds Sign
Code standards as to sign area, height or setback by 15 percent or less shall be
deemed a conforming sign.
C. Grace Period for Permanent Signs in Annexation Areas. Signs that were
installed within the annexation area prior to the effective date of the City's annexation
and became non -conforming upon annexation in the City, may be issued a non-
conforming sign permit that will allow the signs to remain for 10 years from the effective
date of the annexation. This 10-year period shall be known as the "annexation grace
period.".
D. Sign Modifications During the Annexation Grace Period. During the annexation
grace period, signs with non -conforming sign permits may be refaced and the panel or
copy changed, provided the area, height and location of the sign remain unchanged. A
non -conforming sign permit will be issued for work covered under this section.
Permanent signs and sign structures that are moved, replaced or structurally altered
must be brought into conformance with the current Sign Code regulations.
E. Sign Modifications After the Annexation Grace Period. After the annexation
.grace period, the sign is permitted to remain as -is indefinitely. However, relocation, re -
erection, alteration, replacement or change in any way to a legal, non -conforming sign,
including the structure or sign panel/face/copy, will require the sign be brought into
compliance with the sign code in effect at the time of submittal of a complete sign permit
application.
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 5-8-12
BM:bjs Page 9 of 12
17
19.37.030 Non -Conforming Sign Permits
A. Non -Conforming Sign Inventory. The Director shall, as soon as practicable
after the effective date of the annexation, survey the annexation area for signs that do
not conform to the requirements of Title 19. Upon determination that a sign is non-
conforming or illegal, the Director shall use reasonable efforts to notify the sign owner,
in writing and, where practicable, the owner of the property on which the sign is located.
Notification shall include:
1. Whether the sign is non -conforming or illegal.
2. Whether the sign may be eligible for a non -conforming siqn permit. If the
identity of the sign owner cannot be determined after reasonable inquiry, the notice may
be affixed in a conspicuous place on the sign or on the business premises with which
the sign is associated. The failure of the City to identify the sign owner shall not relieve
the property owner from the requirements of this section._
B. Non -Conforming Sign Permits.
1. Eligibility. A non -conforming sign permit may be issued only in accordance
with the standards listed in this chapter.
2. Permit Required. A non -conforming sign permit is required for all eligible
non -conforming signs within the annexation areas. The sign owner shall obtain the
permit within 180 days of notification by the City. Sign permits shall be obtained for any
panel or copy change allowed during the annexation grace period. There is no permit
fee for the issuance of the non -conforming sign permit.
3. Applications. Applications for a non -conforming sign permit shall contain
the name and address of the sign user, the sign owner and the owner of the property
upon which the sign is located, and such other pertinent information as the Director may
require to ensure compliance with this chapter. The Director may waive specific
submittal requirements determined to be unnecessary for review of an application.
4. Failure to Respond. It is the sign owner and/or property owner's responsibility
to return the non -conforming sign permit to the City within the 180 days of notice as
outlined in this section. Failure to respond will constitute a waiver of any grace period
provided to the sign under this chapter and modifications to the sign will be controlled by
TMC Section 19.36.030.
5. Permit Issuance. Any person submifting an application for a non-
conforming sign permit shall use the forms provided by the Department. The Director
shall issue non -conforming sign permits upon a determination of eligibility. The Director
may require the filing of plans or other pertinent information where such information is
necessary to determine compliance with this chapter. Appeals shall be filed in
accordance with TMC Section 19.12.120.
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 5-8-12
BM:bjs Page 10 of 12
in
C. Loss of Legal Non -conforming Status. Non -conforming signs shall be brought
into compliance with this chapter upon the occurrence of one or more of the following
events:
1. When an application is submitted to the City for a project that is subject to
design review, any non -conforming building -mounted signs on the premise affected by
the construction and all non -conforming free-standing signs lose their non -conforming
status.
2. When any panel or copy changes are proposed after the expiration of the
annexation grace period.
3. When the sign meets the definition of abandoned.
4. Damage of 25 percent or more in the value of either the non -conforming
sign or the structure to which it is affixed.
D. Maintenance. Ordinary maintenance and repair of a sign shall be permitted
without loss of non -conforming status if the cost of all maintenance and repair over a
two-year period is less than 25 percent of the cost of replacing the sign.
19.37.040 Non -Conforming Temporary Signs
A. Non -conforming temporary signs in annexation areas must be removed within
120 days of the effective date of the annexation.
B. Commercial real estate signs in existence in the annexation area prior to the
adoption of this code are permitted to remain for up to three months, after which time
the signs must be removed and any future signage must comply with the terms of this
code.
19.37.050 Additional Signage Prohibited
No additional permanent building -mounted signage is permitted on a tenant space that
contains a non -conforming sign. No additional permanent freestanding signs are
permitted on a premises that contains a non -conforming freestanding sign.
Section 12. Corrections by City Clerk o) Code Reviser. Upon approval of the
City Attorney, the City Clerk and the code rev ser are authorized to make necessary
corrections to the ordinance, including corr'Oon of clerical errors; references to other
local, state or federal laws, codes rules/or regulations; or ordinance numbering and
section/subsection numbering.
Section 13. Severability. If any section, subsection, paragraph, sentence, clause
or phrase of this ordinance or its application to any person or situation should be held to
be invalid or unconstitutional for any reason by a court of competent jurisdiction, such
invalidity or unconstitutionality shall not affect the validity or constitutionality of the
remaining portions of this ordinance or its application to any other person or situation.
W:1Word Processing\Ordinances\.Sign Code update 5-8-12
BM:bjs Page 11 of 12
19
Section 14. Effective Date. This ordinance or a summary thereof shall be
published in the official newspaper of the City, and shall take effect and be in full force
five days after passage and publication as provided by law.
PASSED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF TUKWILA, WASHINGTON, at
a Regular Meeting thereof this day of , 2012.
ATTEST/AUTHENTICATED:
Christy O'Flaherty, MMC, City Clerk
APPROVED AS TO FORM BY:
Office of the City Attorney
Jim Haggerton, Mayor
Filed with the City Clerk:
Passed by the City Council:
Published:
Effective Date:
Ordinance Number:
Attachments: A - Map of Billboard Receiving Area (West Valley Hwy.)
B - Map of Billboard Receiving Area (Boeing Access Road and
East Marginal Way South)
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 5-8-12
BM:bjs
Page 12 of 12
411
5
For Illustrative Purposes On
Attachment 6
TU
■
it
' ;1908i
CityofTukwila
Billboard
Receiving
Area
GIS
r�a
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
TUKWILA, WASHINGTON, REVISING THE LAND USE FEE
SCHEDULE TO AMEND FEES RELATED TO CERTAIN TYPES
OF SIGNAGE, AND AMENDING RESOLUTION NO. 1722.
WHEREAS, on August 16, 2010, the City Council of the City of Tukwila adopted
Resolution No. 1722, which established a new fee schedule for land use,
environmental, and sign permit applications; and
WHEREAS, the City Council desires to encourage applicants to submit plans
electronically in order to facilitate the efficient review of sign permits; and
WHEREAS, the City Council wishes to update the fee schedule periodically to
respond to changing business conditions;
NOW THEREFORE THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF TUKWILA,
WASHINGTON, HEREBY RESOLVES AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1. Resolution No. 1722 is hereby amended as follows to include the
following sign permit application fees:
Permit Type
2012 Feel
Retainer
Plus any review
hours over
retainer (2)
Appeal - Zoning, Sign, SEPA, Subdivision Code (P-Appeal) 0)
$541
+ hours over 5
Binding Site Improvement Plan (TMC Chapter 17.16 P-BSIP
$3,497
Boundary Line Adjustment P-BLA/LC
$1,536
Zoning Code and Sign Code Interpretation
TMC Sections 18.96.020 and 19.12.160
$319
Comprehensive Plan Amendment (TMC Chapter 18.80) (P-CPA)
$4,153
+ hours over 40
Conditional Use Permit (P-CUP), Shoreline CUP (1)
$3,554
Design Review (TMC Section 18.60.030 P-DR
Administrative
$2,048
Public Hearing
$3,670
Major Modification
$1,255
Minor Modification
$570
W:\Word Processing\Resolutions\Land Use Fee Schedule amended 4-12-12
BM:bjs Page 1 of 4
23
Permit Type
2012 Feel
Retainer
Plus any review
hours over
retainer (2)
Lot Consolidation P-BLA/LC
$570
Noise Variance TMC Chapter 8.22
Typel
$444
Typell
$599
Type III (1)
$1,332
Planned Residential Development
Administrative TMC Section 18.46.110 P-APRD
$1,990
Public Hearin TMC Section 18.46.110 P-PRD
$5,119
+ hours over 50
Minor Modification TMC Section 18.46.130
$541
Major Modification TMC Section 18.46.130
$2,221
Rezone - Map Change TMC Chapter 18.84 P-R
$3,670
+ hours over 35
Reasonable Use Exception to SAO TMC Section 18.45.180 (1)
$3,071
+ hours over 30
Sensitive Area Master Plan Overlay
TMC Section 18.45.160 P-SAMP
$5,119
+ hours over 50
SEPA Environmental Review TMC Tdle 21 P-SEPA
SEPA Planned Action (P-PACT)
$541
SEPA Checklist
$1,565
SEPA EIS Fee
$3,187
+ hours over 30
SEPA Addendum
$541
Shoreline Environment Re -designation (P-Shore D
$3,670
+ hours over 30
Shoreline Permit Exemption TMC Chapter 18.44
$222
Shoreline Substantial Development Permit (TMC Chapter 18.44)
P-Shore
Project Value $5,000-10,000
$1,082
$10,001 - 50,000
$2,531
+ hours over 25
$50,001 - 500,000
$4,037
+ hours over 40
More than $500,000
$5,119
+ hours over 50
Signs TMC Title 19
Temporary Sin Permit P-T sin TMC Section 19.24.040
$97
Special Event Si na e TMC Section 19.24.060
$97
Permanent Sin Permit P-P sin TMC Chapter 19.20
$222 u
Master Sin Program Administration
$1,990
Master Sin Program BAR
$3,187
Pole Sin Banners Initial Application (TMC Section 19.20.060)
$221 97
Pole Sin Banner Annual Renewal TMC Section 19.20.060
W t5O
Opt Out, Tukwila Urban Center TMC Section 19.22.050
$222
Non -Conforming Sign Permit TMC Section 19.36.040
$0
New Billboard (TMC 19.38.040) or refurbished Billboard
TMC Section 19.38.050
$541
Special Permission P-SP
Caro Container TMC Section 18.50.060
$541
Landscape Perimeter Averaging TMC Section 18.52.020
$541
Parking Standard for Use Not Specified
TMC Section 18.56.100
$541
+ hours over 5
Parking Variance, Modification or Waiver
TMC Sections 18.56.130 and 18.56.140 0)
$888
+ hours over 8
W:\Word Processing\Resolutions\Land Use Fee Schedule amended 4-12-12
BM:bjs Page 2 of 4
24
Permit Type
2012 Feet
Retainer
Plus any review
hours over
retainer (2)
Parking Lot Re -striping
$541
Residential Parking Reduction TMC Section 18,56.065
$541
Shared, Covenant and Complementary Parking Reduction
TMC Section 18.56.070
$541
+ hours over 5
Sensitive Area Deviation, Buffer Reduction TMC Chapter 18.45
$1,507
+ hours over 15
Single Family Design Standard Exception
TMC Section 18.50.055
$541
TSO Special Permission Use TMC Section 18.41.060 lei
$888
Short Plat TMC Chapter 17.12 P-SS
24 Lots
$3,497
5-9 Lots
$3,980
Subdivision Preliminary Approval (TMC Chapter 17.14)
P-SUBP (1)
$5,119
+ hours over 50
Subdivision Final Approval P-SUBP
$3,187
+ hours over 30
Tree Clearing Permit and Exception TMC Chapter 18.54) (P-Tree)
$53
+ hours over 2
Unclassified Use Permit TMC Chapter 18.66 P-UU
$5,119
+ hours over 50
Variance - Zoning, Sign, Shoreline (P-VAR) (1)
$2,588
Wireless Communication Facility TMC Chapter 18.58 P-Wire
Minor
$541
Administrative
$1,536
Major or Height Waiver (1)
$3,071
Zoning Code Text Amendment TMC Chapter 18.80) (P-Code)
$4,153
0) All Hearing Examiner costs will be passed through to the applicant.
(2) The application fee covers the specified number of review hours. Hours over this retainer will be
charged at $92.00 per hour.
(3) The fee for a Permanent Sion Permit (TMC Chapter 19.20) shall be reduced by $50 for a Sion
permit application submitted utilizing the City's electronic plan submittal process.
Fee Type
2012 Feet
Retainer
Plus any review
hours over
retainer
Annexation (P-Annex)
$5,408
Development Agreement (P-DA) *
$1,990
+ hours over 20
Legal Lot Verification
$512
Mailing Label Fee for City to generate labels
$420
Pre -Application Meeting (PREAPP)
$444
Public Notice Mailing Fee
$1 per address, per mailing
Zoning Verification Letter
$319
" The application fee covers the specified number of review hours. Hours over this
retainer will be charged at $92.00 per hour.
W:\Word Processing\Resolutions\Land Use Fee Schedule amended 4-12-12
BM:bjs Page 3 of 4
25
PASSED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF TUKWILA, WASHINGTON, at
a Regular Meeting thereof this day of , 2012.
ATTEST/AUTHENTICATED:
Christy O'Flaherty, MMC, City Clerk Verna Seal, Council President
APPROVED AS TO FORM BY:
Filed with the City Clerk:_
Passed by the City Council:
Resolution Number:
Shelley M. Kerslake, City Attorney
W:\Word Processing\Resolutions\Land Use Fee Schedule amended 4-12-12
BM:bjs Page 4 of 4
26
City of Tukwila
Jim Haggerton, Mayor
INFORMATIONAL MEMORANDUM
TO: Mayor Haggerton
Community Affairs and Parks Committee
FROM: Brandon J. Miles, Senior Planner
DATE: March 19, 2012
SUBJECT: Amendments to Title 19, "Sign Code"
ISSUE
The purpose of tonight's meeting is for Community Affairs and Parks to provide the Department
of Community Development direction on possible changes to Title 19 of the Tukwila Municipal
Code ("TMC"), commonly referred to as the "Sign Code."
BACKGROUND/DISCUSSION
On February 6, 2012, a presentation was made to the City Council regarding the new sign code,
which was adopted in August of 2010. The purpose of the presentation was to provide the City
Council an overview of how the sign code has been received by the community as well as to
initiate the process to make minor amendments to the Sign Code.
Attachment "A" to this staff report is a matrix that outlines those areas of the Sign Code that staff
believes changes are needed. Some of the changes are simply fixing of typos in the original
sign code; other changes require that the City Council provide staff policy direction in order to
address the specific item.
The matrix has been numbered 1-9. The numbers listed below correspond with the matrix
numbers.
Minor Code Amendments- Policy Direction Needed
1. Commercial Signage on Fuel Canopies
The sign code does not allow signage on fuel canopies. This was an oversight in drafting the
sign code and staff recommends amending the sign code to allow a small wall sign on fuel
canopies. The previous sign code allowed one wall sign on a fuel canopy, up to 20% of the
exposed building face.' While 20% of the exposed building face may seem large, in reality, the
small area of the exposed building face of the canopy structure severely limits the size of the
wall sign. In most cases the wall signs installed under the previous sign code ranged in area
between four and eight square feet.
1 TMC 19.32.160 (2)
M�
INFORMATIONAL MEMO
Page 2
L
a�a
Staff Recommendation
Staff recommends that service stations be permitted to install one flush mounted building wall
per elevation on fuel canopies. The sign can be illuminated, with a maximum size of five square
feet.
2. Streamline Permit Process for Conforming Freestanding Signs.
The Sign Code requires that a permit be obtained for any reface or copy change to an existing
freestanding sign. However, the code requirement is burdensome to owners of freestanding
signs that comply with the City's sign code.
Staff Recommendation
Staff would like to allow refaces and copy changes to freestanding signs that meet the current
code to be accomplished without having to obtain a new permit. Thus, a property owner would
only have to obtain a permit once.
3. Electronic Plan Submittal
Many cities are moving to electronic plan submittals for all types of permits. Electronic plan
submittal allows for permits to be submitted via email with fees paid using credit cards. Review
of plans submitted electronically is also done electronically, essentially the process is "paper
free." DCD is hoping to start accepting permits electronically when the City switches to a new
permit system in 2013. Electronic submittal of sign permits is a logical first step in moving the
entire City to electronic plan submittal. Sign permits are fairly straight forward and have a very
basic review process. Staff would like to encourage contractors to move to electronic plan
submittal by reducing the permit fee for those contractors who take advantage of the system.
ZADCD n ClerftBrandonffverton DAICAP, 2012.03.26\2012 Memo - for merge.doc
28
INFORMATIONAL MEMO
Page 3
Staff Recommendation
Staff recommends that the permit fee for sign permits submitted electronically be reduced by
$50.
4. Annexation Areas
The City has two remaining potential annexation areas. Upon annexation, the City will have to
address a range of issues related to non -conformities, including non -conforming signs. Staff
would like to be proactive in this area by adopting code language that will specify the regulation
of non -conforming signs in certain areas upon annexation.
In order to reduce the impact of the new sign code, the City provided a grace period for signs
that met the provisions of the old sign code, but became non -conforming with the adoption of
the new sign code. For example, freestanding signs that became non -conforming were
provided a ten year grace period before they were required to come into compliance with the
current sign code regulation. The grace period ends in August of 2010. Under the grace period,
freestanding signs can be refaced and copy change, with a permit, provided there are no
structural alternations to the sign. Staff believes a similar concept can be employed for
annexation areas.
ZADCD n ClerftBrandonlRiverton DAICAP, 2012.03.2612012 Memo -for merge.doc
29
INFORMATIONAL MEMO
Page 4
North Annexation areas, which includes signage which may become
non -conforming upon annexation to the City.
Z:IDCD n Clerk's\BrandonlRiverton DAICAP, 2012.03.2612012 Memo -for merge.doc
30
INFORMATIONAL MEMO
Page 5
Staff Recommendation
Provide signs in annexation areas with a ten year grace period, which would start on the
effective date of the annexation. Signs may be refaced and receive copy changes, with a permit,
during the grace period.
5. Add Airport Way as a Billboard'Receiving Area
In order to encourage the removal of billboards within the City, the City Council established two
"billboard receiving areas". The purpose of these billboard receiving areas is to provide
locations for new billboards, provided a set number of billboards are removed within "designated
sending areas." TMC 19.08.067 establishes the following two billboard receiving areas:
a. The southern billboard receiving area includes all of West Valley Highway, south of S.
180th Street and all of S. 180th Street east of West Valley Highway.
b. The northern billboard receiving areas includes all properties along East Marginal Way,
north of Boeing Access Road and all properties along Boeing Access Road.
Establishment of the billboard receiving areas was an attempt to to balance areas of the City
where the Council would accept billboard structures, while at the same time establishing areas
in which billboard companies would be willing to locate. The receiving areas are generally
heavy and light industrial areas, which are distant from the urban core and residential areas.
The sending areas are all areas of the City that are not designed as billboard receiving areas
zones (TMC 19.08.069).
An applicant must secure the removal of existing billboards in order to install a new billboard in
one of the two designed receiving areas. Billboards that are to be removed must be located in
sending areas. TMC 19.38 provides a specific formula, which requires that the applicant
remove more billboards within the sending areas than is proposed to be installed. To provide
an example of this code at work: a new billboard has been approved to be constructed at the
southeast corner of West Valley Highway and S. 180th Street. The proposed billboard will have
one face and pursuant to TMC 19.38.040 the applicant is required to secure the removal of
three billboard faces. Given that the r billboard must be removed within the designed "sending
area," the applicant has proposed to remove two billboard structures along Tukwila International
Boulevard and one along East Marginal Way.
In administering the billboard code staff realized that Airport Way was not included as a
billboard receiving area and thus, by definition, is a billboard sending area. The properties along
Airport Way have the same land use as those along East Marginal Way. The primary reason to
include Airport Way as a billboard receiving zone is so billboard companies do not propose to
remove existing billboards along Airport Way in order to get credit for new billboard construction.
In staff's opinion, the City should focus on billboard removal within the core of Tukwila
International Blvd and near residential zones.
Staff Recommendation
Include Airport Way as a billboard receiving area.
6. Pole Banners fee and Expansion of Allowable Zones
The Sign Code allows for the display of banners on lights poles within parking lights within the
Tukwila Urban Center (TUC). The purpose of allowing these banners was to encourage a
festive style of signage at commercial developments. Unfortunately, no property owner has
ZADCD n CleriesTrandonlRiverton DAICAR 2012.03.26\2012 Memo - for merge.doc
31
INFORMATIONAL MEMO
Page 6
taken advantage of the ability to install these banners. In talking with property owners it seems
that the permit fee of $222 for the installation is a deterrent.
The banners are also only permitted for commercial properties in the TUC zone. With Tukwila
Village moving forward staff thinks it would be useful to allow properties in the Neighborhood
Commercial Center (NCC) to be able to install pole banners. This would allow the Tukwila
Village site and other properties along TIB to install flag pole banners.
Staff Recommendation
Reduce the permit fee for pole banner applications to $25 for the initial application and $15 for
the renewal; allow pole banners to be displayed in the NCC zone.
7. LEED and Built Green Certification
The City of Tukwila has very few incentives for encouraging the construction of LEED and Built
Green Buildings. The sign code provides an avenue for rewarding development in the City that
is built to reduce its environmental impacts. Recently, Starbucks built the City's first LEED
certified building on East Marginal Way South. As part of this review process, staff learned that
often times the LEED process requires that educational signage be installed to provide
education to users of the site. Staff would suggest a nominal bonus be permitted for LEED and
Built Green Certified Buildings.
Staff Recommendation
Staff proposes that structures that are certified as LEED or Built Green be permitted to have a
one percent increase in sign area for any allowed freestanding sign and a .5% area increase for
all permitted wall signs.
Housing Keeping
Staff recommends that the following housekeeping items be amended in the Sign Code.
8. Add notes on Billboard Receiving Maps (Exhibit A and B of Code)
Some confusion exists between the maps (Exhibits A and B of the Sign Code) and the specific
code language regarding which areas of the City are designated as billboard receiving areas.
The maps inadvertently left off some areas of the City that were specifically called out in the
Code language. Staff has applied the specific code language; however, staff would like to
provide a note on exhibits A and B which would clarify the issue.
9. Correct scriber's error in TMC 19.20.050 (4)
A scriber's error at TMC 19.20.050 (F)(4)(b) needs to be fixed. Subsection 5 should actually be
subsection "c". This not a policy change, but simply fixes an error in the original Ordinance.
ZADCD n Clerk'slBrandonkfterton DAICAP, 2012.03.26\2012 Memo - for merge.doc
32
INFORMATIONAL MEMO
Page 7
RECOMMENDATION
The goal of this evening's meeting is for the Committee to provide policy direction on the
proposed amendments to Title 19 outlined above. The Committee can also ask staff to examine
any other amendments to Title 19 that it feels are needed. Based on the outcome of tonight's
meeting, staff will come back to the Committee on April 9, 2012 that represents the
recommendation of the Committee. Staff anticipated a public hearing to be held on April 23,
2012, with possible Council action on May 7, 2012.
ATTACHMENTS
A. Matrix of Proposed Sign Code Updates
ZADCD n CleftlBrandon\Riverton DA\CAP, 2012.03.26\2012 Memo - for merge.doc
33
CA)
Title 19 Sign Code Amendments, CAP Meeting, March 26, 2012 Attachment A
#
Topic
Suggested Policy
Impact on business and
Other Considerations
property owners?
1.
Commercial Signage on Fuel Canopies
Allow fuel canopies to have
Would increase the
None
signs under specific
allowable signage for service
The existing code has no provisions for the
limitations.
stations.
placement of signage on fuel canopies at service
stations. Such signage is common place and
usually is the primary signage for gas stations.
2.
Streamline Permit Process for Conforming
Streamline the permit
Copy changes to existing
There will be a slight
Freestanding Signs.
process for freestanding signs
freestanding signs that meet
reduction in the sign permit
that meeting code.
code will not require a sign
fees generated by the City.
Currently, the City requires a permit to reface a
permit which will save
However, fees are used to
freestanding sign that meets code.
Tukwila businesses and
offset City time in reviewing
property owners time and
sign permit applications and
money.
not a revenue generating
source.
3.
Electronic Plan Submittal
Electronic plan submittal
Reduces permit fees for
Staff is currently working to
saves time and money for the
businesses, property
implement electronic plan
Reduce the fee paid by applicants who take
City and applicant as well as
owners, and contractors.
submittal. The fee
advantage of electronic plan submittal.
reducing greenhouse gases
reduction will not take place
by reducing contractors' trips
until the system is up and
to City Hall. Providing a
running.
financial incentive would
encourage people to use the
program. Staff is proposing
$SO reduction in permit fees
for each permanent sign that
is submitted electronically.
4.
Annexation Areas
When the City adopted the
No impact to current
None
previous sign code, signs that
Tukwila property owners or
The potential north annexation area includes
met the provision of the old
businesses. Business and
many existing signs. The City is working to
sign code but were made
property owners within
#
Topic
Suggested Policy
Impact on business and
property owners?
Other Considerations
complete the annexation and once the annexation
non -conforming were
annexation areas will
is complete, the City will have to address many
provided specific grace
eventually have to bring
non -conforming issues, including non -conforming
periods. The length of the
signs in compliance. By
signs.
grace period was dependent
adopting this policy before
on whether the sign was a
the City completes any
freestanding sign or a
annexations it provides clear
freeway interchange sign.
direction to property owners
Staff suggests that a similar
and businesses on what to
approach be used for
expect after annexation.
annexation areas. Any legally
The policy also creates a
installed signs in an
level playing field for
annexation area may remain
existing businesses and
and have unlimited refaces
property owners in the city
for up to ten years from the
and those that may
effective date of the
eventually be annexed into
annexation. Once the ten
the City.
year period has expired the
sign may remain, but any
reface or copy change would
require conformance to the
City's sign code.
S.
Add Airport Way to Billboard Receiving Area.
Designate Airport Way as a
Would allow properties
The code change is needed
billboard receiving zone. Staff
along Airport Way to be
to reflect the City's policy
The sign code provides both a map and a
suggestion would be that all
eligible for new billboards or
priorities for billboard
definition of which areas of the City are eligible for
properties north of Boeing
conversion of existing
removal in in residential and
new billboards. During original designation of the
access road and east of
billboards into digital
neighborhood commercial
billboard receiving area Airport Way was not
Interstate 5 be considered as
billboards.
areas such as the core of
included as being eligible for new billboards. By
a Billboard Receiving Zone.
Tukwila International Blvd.
not including the area as a billboard receiving
Airport Way South is heavy
area, it allows billboards from the area to be
industrial and therefore
removed and counted towards the credit to
more appropriate as a
installing new billboards. There are other more
receiving rather than
W
Cn
GO
#
Topic
Suggested Policy
Impact on business and
Other Considerations
property owners?
pressing areas of the City where the City wants to
sending location for
see billboards removed.
billboards.
6.
Pole Banners
1. Reduce the permit
1. Reduces permit fees
None
fee for pole banners
for applicants which
The sign code allows pole banners on private light
from $222 to $25.
will hopefully
poles in the TUC. A permit is required to install
Renewal of the
encourage property
the banners. No property owners have taken
permit will only cost
owners to install
advantage of the allowable banners. Staffs
$15.
decorative banners.
conversations with property owners had indicating
2. Allow pole banners
2. Would expand the
that the permit fee discourages the banner
on private light
use of light pole
installation.
standards in the NCC
banners to
zones.
properties zoned
NCC zones, such as the Tukwila Village site, are not
NCC, including the
permitted to have pole banners. Staff would like
Tukwila Village site.
to encourage these banners in the NCC.
7.
LEED and Built Green Certification
Reward property owners that
Provides a benefit to
None.
obtain LEED and Built Green
property owners that invest
certification for their
in energy and environmental
investments. Allow a small
upgrades to new and
1% size increase for
existing buildings.
freestanding signs and a .5%
increase for all flush mounted
signs.
8.
Add notes on Billboard Receiving Maps (Exhibit A
Clarify that the maps are
No impact.
None.
and B of Code)
reference only, but that the
specific code language
governs.
9.
Correct scribner's error in TMC 19.20.050 (4)
Not a policy change.
No change from current sign
N/A
code.
City of Tukwila
• Community Affairs and Parks Committee
COMMUNITY AFFAIRS AND PARKS COMMITTEE
Meeting Minutes
March 26, 2012 — 5: 00 p. m.
PRESENT
Councilmembers: Kathy Hougardy, Chair; Joe Duffie and Allan Ekberg
Staff: Nora Gierloff, Derek Speck, David Cline, Rick Still, Dave Johnson, Peggy McCarthy, Brandon
Miles and Kimberly Matej
Guests: Chuck Parrish, resident
CALL TO ORDER: Committee Chair Hougardy called the meeting to order at 5:01 p.m.
I. PRESENTATIONS
No presentations.
II. BUSINESS AGENDA
A. Sir► Code Revisions
Staff is seeking Committee direction regarding several suggested policy changes to the current Sign Code
which was adopted by the Council in August 2010. The Sign Code has been in existence for over a year and
staff has had the opportunity to identify areas of the Code which need clarification, simplification or basic
housekeeping such as typographical errors. The suggested amendments are outlined below followed by
Committee direction in bold, if appropriate.
• Allow for signage on fuel canopies. This was inadvertently left out of the current code. The
Committee commented that they would like staff to define fuel canopy.
• In regards to freestanding signs that comply with the City's Sign Code, if there is going to be a reface
or copy change to an existing sign currently in compliance, a second permit will not need to be
secured.
• Reduce sign permit fee by $50 for applications submitted electronically. Permit cost is currently
$222.
• Provide annexation areas with the same 10-year grace period afforded in the current Sign Code when
and if the areas are annexed. The grace period would commence on the effective date of the
annexation.
• Expand the north billboard receiving areas to include Airport Way.
• Add Airport Way as a third billboard receiving area in the City.
• Reduce the sign permit fee for pole banners on private property from $222 to an initial application fee
of $25 and a $15 renewal. Additionally, allow pole banners in the Neighborhood Commercial Center.
Committee Members are interested in the pole banner fee reflecting an amount more in line
with other fees (such as the temporary sign permit fee).
• Recognizing that many LEED and/or Green Built buildings require educational language on the
property to explain the site/building significance, such buildings will be permitted a 1% increase for
free standing signs and a 0.5% increase for permitted wall signs.
Staff will make the appropriate changes and return to Committee on April 9 for review and recommendation
to full Council. Committee Member Ekberg expressed interest in allowing digital and animated displays in the
City to modernize and increase the effectiveness of information sharing_ RETURN TO COMMITTEE ON
APRIL 9 WITH RECOMMENDED CHANGES AND DRAFT ORDINANCE/RESOLUTION.
MA
COMMUNITY AFFAIRS AND PARKS COMMITTEE
Meeting Minutes
April 23, 2012 — 5: 00 p.m.
PRESENT
Councilmembers: Kathy Hougardy, Chair; Joe Duffie and Allan Ekberg
Staff: David Cline, Nora Gierloff, Brandon Miles and Kimberly Matej
Guests: Sharon Mann
CALL TO ORDER: Committee Chair Hougardy called the meeting to order at 5:01 p.m.
I. PRESENTATIONS
No presentations.
II. BUSINESS AGENDA
A. Resolution: Tukwila Tree and Environment Advisory Committee
As part of the periodic review and update of the City's Comprehensive Plan as required by the Growth
Management Act, staff is beginning the process of updating the Natural Environment chapter of the City's
Plan. Staff is seeking Council approval of a resolution that forms a Tukwila Tree and Advisory Committee
and outlines the Committee's responsibilities to assist in public input with revisions to this chapter.
If formed, this Committee is anticipated to have 7-10 members who would meet on a monthly basis for 6-8
months. Staff believes this Committee could begin meeting as early as August. The Committee will be tasked
with providing recommendations for City policy on natural resource issues including, but not limited to: tree
canopy, tree protection, landscaping in commercial and industrial areas, street tree management and planning,
maintenance of forest and trees in parks and other areas that are covered in the City's Tree Ordinance and
other related regulations in the City's Comprehensive Plan. The review of these recommendations will first go
to the Planning Commission for additional review and recommendation and then on to Council for final
review and discussion.
The informational memo submitted by staff suggests one Councilmember sit on the Advisory Committee.
Committee Chair Hougardy suggested that the Council representative be a member of the Community Affairs
& Parks Committee. Committee Member Ekberg suggested that the idea of a "tree bank" be considered
during the review process.
Sharon Mann was in attendance at the meeting and expressed concern about tree regulations that could be
anti -development. UNANIMOUS APPROVAL. FORWARD TO MAY 14 FOR DISCUSSION.
B. Sign Code Amendments and Fee Resolution
At the March 26, 2012, Community Affairs & Parks Committee, staff presented proposed amendments to the
Sign Code. Staff is now bringing forth a draft ordinance reflecting those changes and recommendations made
by the Committee for recommendation to the Council for review and approval. Additionally, staff is seeking
Council direction on a policy level item as outlined on the next page.
Since the March 26 meeting, staff has:
• Defined fuel canopy which includes alternative fuel stations
• Pole banner fees will be $97 for initial applications and $50 for renewals (same as temporary sign permit)
• Recommending against pole banners in the NCC
• Allow pole banners in Public Recreation Overlays (golf course, parks, schools, community centers)
• Added language addressing non -conforming signs in annexation areas
W
Community Affairs & Parks Commiftee Minutes April 23, 2012 — Page 2
Staff added a section in the current information memo regarding non -conforming signs which was not
discussed at the March 26 Committee meeting. Staff is seeking Council direction on this item, which is
summarized next.
A total of 174 property/sign owners have been informed of their non -conforming sign status. These notices
required a response to the City from the property/sign owner in order to take advantage of a grace period. Of
174 sent notices, 123 notices were responded to and 44 are outstanding. Staff is seeking Council input on
whether or not the Council would like staff to begin enforcing TMC 19.36, which calls for the removal of the
non -conforming signs whose owners have been non -responsive. Staff also stated that the Code language
could be modified to provide additional options. The Committee Members were in favor of upholding the
current Code as written, but recognize that a policy level discussion is needed with the full Council regarding
this decision. UNANIMOUS APPROVAL. FORWARD TO MAY 14 COW FOR PUBLIC HEARING
AND DISCUSSION.
C. Parks & Recreation Annual Report
As information only, staff presented the 2011 Parks & Recreation Annual Report. This report provides a
broad overview of parks, general programs, teens and youth, seniors, facilities, volunteers and the pool. Staff
also included copies of the 2011 recaps for the Recreation Division and Events Division both of which
provide more detail of programming and activities. These two recaps were discussed in detail at previous
Committee meetings.
Committee Member Ekberg complimented staff on the Events Division recap explaining that it is a document
that can be utilized to make decisions regarding processes in the future due to informational presentation of
comparable and historical data. He did not feel that the Recreation Division recap could be utilized in the
same way. INFORMATION ONLY.
D. Parks & Recreation Event Calendar
As information only, Committee Members reviewed the Parks & Recreation events calendar for May and
June. INFORMATION ONLY.
III. MISCELLANEOUS
Meeting adjourned at 5:51 p.m.
Next meeting: Monday, May 14, 2012 — 5:00 p.m. — Conference Room #3
kg�'q Committee Chair Approval
Minutq by Xkr.4. Reviewed by NG & BM.
39
Section Removed from the Ordinance by Community Affairs and Parks
Section 11. TMC Section 19.36.040, "Non -Conforming Sign Permits," Amended.
Ordinance No. 2303 §10 (part), as codified at TMC Section 19.36.040, subparagraphs B. and
C., is hereby amended to read as follows:
B. Non -Conforming Sign Permits.
1. Eligibility. A non -conforming sign permit may be issued only in accordance with
the standards listed in this chapter.
2. Permit Required. A non -conforming sign permit is required for all eligible non-
conforming signs within the City. The sign owner shall obtain the permit within 180 days of
notification by the City and for any panel or copy changes allowed during the grace period.
3. Applications. Applications for a non -conforming sign permit shall contain the
name and address of the sign user, the sign owner and the owner of the property upon which
the sign is located, and such other pertinent information as the Director may require to ensure
compliance with this chapter. The Director may waive specific submittal requirements
determined to be unnecessary for review of an application.
4. Permit Issuance. Any person submitting an application for a non -conforming sign
permit shall use the forms provided by the Department. The Director shall issue non-
conforming sign permits upon a determination of eligibility. The Director may require the filing of
plans or other pertinent information where such information is necessary to determine
compliance with this chapter. Appeals shall be filed in accordance with TMC Section 19.12.120.
C. Loss of Legal Non -Conforming Status_ Non -conforming signs shall either be removed__ _ - Formatted: Font: (Default)Ariel, Not Bold,
or immediately brought into compliance with this chapter upon the occurrence of one or more of Italic
the following events:
21 _ When an application is submitted to the City for a project that is subject to design
review, any non -conforming building -mounted signs on the premise affected by the construction
and all non -conforming free-standing signs lose their non -conforming status.
42. When any panel or copy changes are proposed after the expiration of the grace
period.
43. When the sign meets the definition of abandoned.
64. Damage of 25 percent or more in the value of either the non -conforming sign or
the structure to which it is affixed.
M
City of Tukwila
Jim Haggerton, Mayor
Department of Community Development Jack Pace, Director
DETERMINATION OF NON -SIGNIFICANCE (DNS) ADDENDUM
Description of Original Proposal:
In August of 2010, the City Council adopted a new Title 19 of the Tukwila Municipal Code, commonly
referred to as the "Sign Code." Prior the City Council's adoption, the SEPA Responsible Official issued a
Determination of Non -Significance (DNS) on March 12, 2010.
The new Title 19 replaced the City's previous sign code, which had been in place for almost 30-years. A
wide range of signs were permitted under the new sign code. The SEPA Responsible Official reviewed a
SEPA Checklist and staff report on the impacts of the new sign code before issuing the DNS.
For the last two years, City staff has been administering the new sign code and through this
administration, has realized that there were some oversights in the new sign code. To address the issues
that have been identified over the last two years, the City Council is considering minor amendments to the
Sign Code.
These minor amendments include:
1. Allowing small signs on fuel canopies;
2. Streamlining the Permit Process for certain freestanding signs;
3. Providing a fee discount for sign permits that are submitted electronically;
4. Expand the north billboard receiving area to include Airport Way;
5. Allowing Pole Banners in public recreation overlay zones;
6. Providing a sign area increase for LEED certified buildings; and
7. Minor edits to the adopted code to add clarification and to correct scribner's errors.
The SEPA Responsible Official concluded that additional environmental review is not needed for the
proposed amendments and that proposed, minor amendments are consistent with the original SEPA
checklist that was reviewed by the City in March of 2010.
Proponent: City of Tukwila
Location of Proposal: Citywide
Lead Agency City Of Tukwila
File Number: E10-008
6300 Southcenter Boulevard, Suite #100 - Tukwila, Washington 98188 - Phone 206-431-3670 - Fax 206-431-3665
The City has determined that the addendum does not have a probable significant adverse impact on the
environment. An environmental impact statement (EIS) is not required under RCW 43.21c.030 (2) (c).
This decision was made after review of a completed environmental checklist and other information on
file' with the lead agency. This information is available to the public on request. The original DNS was
issued on March 12, 2010.
— � OL
Jac Pace, SEPA Responsible Official for the City of Tukwila, Washington
6300 Southcenter Boulevard
Tukwila, WA 98188
(206) 431-3670
Staff Contact: Brandon J. Miles, Senior Planner
(206) 431-3684
' The following document is adopted by reference to this SEPA Addendum, Staff Report to the Tukwila City Council dated
April 11, 2012.
Page 2 of 2
City of Tukwila
Jim Haggerton, Mayor
INFORMATIONAL MEMORANDUM
TO: Mayor Haggerton
Community Affairs and Parks Committee
FROM: Jack Pace, DCD Director
BY: Brandon J. Miles, Senior Planner
DATE: April 11, 2012
SUBJECT: Amendments to Title 19, "Sign Code"
ISSUE
Should amendments be made to Title 19 of the Tukwila Municipal Code (TMC), commonly
referred to as the "Sign Code?"
BACKGROUND/DISCUSSION
On March 26, 2012, staff presented a memo to Community Affairs and Parks (CAP) dated
March 19, 2012 that outlined nine proposed amendments to the City's Sign Code. A copy of
that memo, the meeting minutes, a proposed Ordinance in strikeout/underlined format and a
proposed draft fee resolution are attached. Generally, CAP was supportive of the proposed
amendments, but required some clarification and additional discussion.
NOTE: In this memo, staff has also added an item regarding non -conforming signs. The issue
of non -conforming signs was not discussed at the March 26th meeting, but staff would like to
propose a change to certain non -conforming regulations. See below for more information.
1. Commercial Signage on Fuel Canopies
CAP was supportive of this proposed code change, but requested that DCD staff add a
definition for fuel canopy. At the CAP meeting there was some concern that without a clear
definition canopies throughout the City would be eligible for signage. DCD staff proposes the
following definition:
Fuel Canopy is a structure designed to provide weather protection to motorists in order for them
to fill vehicles with: gasoline, diesel, compressed natural gas, propane, electricity or other similar
compounds which allow for the powering of vehicles. The following components must be in
place beneath the structure in order for this definition to apply to a structure, 1) There must be at
least two fuel dispensing devices; and 2) Customers must have the ability to pay electronically
beneath the structure.
The above definition would allow all traditional gas stations to install signage on fuel canopies --
as well as alternative fuel stations, such as the new Blue Star Gas Propane business.
Staff proposes that a fuel canopy be permitted to have one illuminated or non -illuminated sign
for each elevation, with the sign being permitted to be no more than five square feet.
7
INFORMATIONAL MEMO
Page 2
2. Streamline Permit Process for Conforming Freestanding Signs
CAP was supportive of this proposal. New language was added to TMC 19.12.030 "Exceptions -
Sign Permits Not Required," which states that permits are not required for copy changes and
refaces if the work complies with the requirements of TMC 19.20 (Permanent Signs) or 19.32
(Master Sign Program). The language in TMC 19.20 and 19.32 is identical and states the
following:
A monument sign permitted under this section is permitted to complete refaces, panel
changes and copy changes without the need to obtain a new permit, provided ALL of the
following criteria are met. -
a. The monument sign was authorized by the City under a permit issued on or after
August 24, 2010. .
b. The property owner, or authorized agent of the property owner, was the applicant to
secure the permit as required under this section.
c. As part of the reface and copy change, there can be no structural changes to the
sign which result in a change of sign or message areas, modification in sign height,
inclusion of a dynamic sign component, or change in the monument sign's location.
d. That within 30-days of completion of the copy change or reface, the property owner
or authorized agent shall transmit to the City a Notice of Copy Change form with a
photo of the revised sign face.
3. Electronic Plan Submittal
CAP was supportive of this proposal. The draft resolution reduces permit fees by $50 for
applications for permanent signs that are submitted electronically.
4. Annexation Areas
Staff proposed providing existing signs within annexation areas a ten year grace period that
would commence upon the effective date of the annexation. CAP was supportive of this
proposal. A new chapter to Title 19 is being proposed; see Section 19.37 of the draft
Ordinance. The Chapter will be TMC 19.37 and will be called "Non -Conforming Signs in
Annexation Areas." The language of this Chapter is nearly identical to the language found in
TMC 19.36 (Non -Conforming Provisions), except that language is inserted to refer to the
effective date of annexation and not the effective date of the original sign Ordinance.
5. Add Airport Way as a Billboard Receiving Area
Staff brought up a concern with the fact that Airport Way was not included in the definition of
"billboard receiving area," provided in TMC 19.08.067. Staff proposed to add Airport Way to the
areas of the City eligible for new billboards, and CAP was supportive of the proposal.
Staff proposes the following changes to TMC 19.08.067:
`Billboard Receiving Areas" are those areas of the City along South 180th Street zoned as
Commercial/Light Industrial; those properties south of South 180th Street along West Valley
Highway zoned as Commercial/Light Industrial; all properties located along Boeing Access
Road; those properties along East Marginal Way, north of Boeing Access Road; and all
properties located along Airport Way, north of Boeing Access road, for which
8 ZMCD n Clerles\Brandon\Sign Cade Update\CAP, 2012.04-23\InfoMemo.doc
INFORMATIONAL MEMO
Page 3
permits for new billboards may be issued if the criteria of this Title are satisfied. Attachment D
and E are maps that show the billboard receiving areas listed with this definition. Attachments D
and E are for illustrative purposes only. a
6. Pole Banners fee and Expansion of Allowable Zones
DCD staff discussed two specific items regarding pole banner; the first was the fee; and the
second was the issue of expanding the allowable zones where pole banners could be used.
a. Fee. Staff had initially suggested that the fee for pole banners be $25 for the initial fee 11iU
and $15 for renewals. CAP expressed interest in ensuring that the pole banner fee was
reflective of other land use and sign permit fees, specifically the temporary sign permit
fee which currently is $97. The attached resolution reflects the pole banner fee being
$97 for the initial application and $50 for renewals.
b. Additional Zones. DCD staff had proposed allowing pole banners in the Neighborhood
Commercial Center (NCC) zone. One of the reasons to allow pole banners in the NCC
zones was so that Tukwila Village would be able to install such signs. CAP did seem not
to have any objections to the proposed change, but there did seem to be some
hesitation in how the pole banners could be used. As staff noted, the City cannot
regulate content of signs, including pole banners. Staff is now proposing that pole
banners not be allowed in the NCC zone. Much of the NCC zone is located on Tukwila
International Boulevard (TIB), and staff is concerned that properties in the area may not
install high quality pole signs --which would hinder the City's ongoing efforts to revitalize
the area.
During the CAP meeting, the Parks Department discussed a possible desire to install
pole banners at Foster Golf Course; currently, the Sign Code prohibits such signage.
DCD staff would like to propose that areas of the City that are subject to the Public
Recreation Overlay be permitted to install pole banners. This change would allow pole
banners to be installed at all Tukwila Schools, most City parks, the Community Center
and Fort Dent Park.
7. LEED Certification
CAP was supportive of a small sign area bonus for LEED certified buildings. The proposed
Ordinance reflects the recommendation in the March 19, 2012 memo.
8. Add Notes to Billboard Receiving Maps
CAP was supportive of staffs proposal to add a note on two maps in the Code that state that
the maps are for "Illustrative Purposes Only." Staff also added some language in the definition
of "billboard receiving area" to further clarify that the definition will govern in the event of a
conflict between the definition and the maps, see item 5 above.
9. Correct scribner's error in TMC 19.20.050 (4)
CAP had no concerns with fixing the scribner's error identified above.
Update on the Removal of Non -Conforming Signs
Staff would also request policy direction from CAP on an issue related to the removal of non-
conforming signs within the City. This issue was not discussed previously.
ZADCD n ClerWs\Brandon\Sign Code Update\CAP, 2012.04-23VnfoMemo.doc 9
INFORMATIONAL MEMO
Page 4
As CAP is aware, the City strived to lessen the impact of the new code on businesses within the
City. Due to the fact that the City moved to monument only signage, many freestanding signs in
the City became non -conforming upon the effective date of the new sign code. The rights
associated with each individual sign vary based on the degree to which the sign is non-
conforming. TMC 19.36.040 establishes three non -conforming categories:
a. Signs which were non -conforming under the OLD sign code. These signs may
remain indefinitely, but a reface or copy change is not permitted without bringing the
sign into conformance with the City's sign code. In most cases "bringing the sign into
conformance' requires removal of the sign.
b. Signs which became non -conforming with adoption of the new sign code and
obtained non -conforming sign permits. These signs are provided a ten-year grace
period. During the grace period the signs may have refaces and copy changes, with
a permit. After the grace period the sign may remain indefinitely, but a reface or
copy change is not permitted without bringing the sign into conformance.
c. Non -Conforming Freeway Interchange Signs. All freeway interchange signs became
non -conforming under the new sign code. Freeway interchange signs are provided a
five year grace period in which copy changes and refaces are permitted, with a
permit. After the grace period the sign may remain indefinitely, but a reface or copy
change is not permitted without bringing the sign into conformance.
TMC 19.36.040 requires that property and/or sign owners obtain a no -fee, non -conforming sign
permit for any sign on their premise which does not meet the sign code. Property owners
and/or sign owners must have obtained the non -conforming permit within 180-days of being
notified by the City that their signs are non -conforming. Non -conforming rights are lost if the
property owner and/or sign owner failed to submit the non -conforming permit within the 180-day
period (TMC 19.36.040). 'n o
The City has sent out a total of 174 notices to property owners and/or sign owners informing
them that their signs are non -conforming. A total 123 response' to the City's notification were
received back. A total of 44 never responded to the City's notification that their signs were non-
conforming and thus under TMC 19.36.040 the signs should be removed.
Staff would like policy direction from the City Council on the following question: Should the City
begin to enforce the provisions of TMC 19.36, requiring that 44 signs be removed within the
City? An advantage of this approach would be that a significant number of non -conforming signs
would be removed and thus improve the City's streetscape and the overall urban environment.
A disadvantage of this approach would be the impact the removal would have on businesses
and property owners who, once receiving the Notice and Order, may approach the City Council
to amend the code requirements.
Staff would like to propose an alternative: Any sign that did not obtain the non -conforming sign
permit, as required, would be permitted to remain indefinitely; however any proposed copy
change or reface would require that the sign be brought up to the provisions of the City's sign
code. This approach would still result in the removal of non -conforming signs, but over a longer
time frame.
1 89 submitted the non -conforming permit; 25 were received by the City and are pending; two went through the
Master Sign Program; and seven used the opt -out language.
10 ZADCD n Cledfs\&andon\Sign Code Update\CAP, 2012.04-23\InfoMemo.doc
INFORMATIONAL MEMO
Page 5
FINANCIAL IMPACT
Permit fees will be reduced by not requiring permits for certain refaces and copy changes.
However, permit fees are meant to compensate the City for time reviewing the permit and are
not meant to generate revenue. By waiving certain permits, it will free up staff to work on other
current and long range projects.
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends that the attached Ordinance and Resolution be forward to the May 14'h
Committee of the Whole meeting for a public hearing and discussion by the full Council. Action
on the Ordinance and Resolution is anticipated at the May 21st Regular Council Meeting.
ATTACHMENTS
• Draft Ordinance;
• Draft Resolution;
• Staff's memo from March 19, 2012; and
• Minutes from the March 26, 2012 Community Affairs and Parks Meeting.
ZADCD n Clerks\Brandon\Sign Code Update\CAP, 2012-04-23\I0oMemo.doc 11
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
TUKWILA, WASHINGTON, UPDATING AND EXPANDING THE
SIGN CODE, AS CODIFIED IN TUKWILA MUNICIPAL CODE
TITLE 19, TO RESPOND TO THE NEEDS OF BUSINESSES AND
TO ADDRESS THE CHANGING URBAN LANDSCAPE OF THE
CITY; AMENDING ORDINANCE NO. 2303; PROVIDING FOR
SEVERABILITY; AND ESTABLISHING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Tukwila recognizes that signs are an
important component of the built environment and assist in way -finding, advertising and
personal expression for Tukwila businesses, property owners and residents; and
WHEREAS, regulation of signage is needed in order to preserve and protect the
public welfare, preserve and enhance the appearance of the built environment, control
visual clutter; protect private and public property, and ensure the orderly movement of
motorized and non -motorized forms of transportation; and
.WHEREAS, on August 16, 2010, the Tukwila City Council adopted a new,
comprehensive Sign Code for the City of Tukwila, which is codified in Title 19 of the
Tukwila Municipal Code; and
WHEREAS, the Tukwila City Council desires to regularly update the City's
regulations regarding signage in order to respond to the needs of Tukwila businesses
and to address the ongoing changing urban landscape of the City; and
WHEREAS, on April 2, 2012, as required by the Growth Management Act, the City
filed notice with the Washington State Department of Commerce that the City intended
to adopt revisions to the Sign Code; and
WHEREAS, on April 24, 2012, the Director of Community Development determined
that the proposed amendments to Title 19 do not have a probable significant adverse
impact on the environment and issued a Determination of Non -Significance; and
WHEREAS, on May 14, 2012, following public notice, the City Council held a public
hearing to receive testimony regarding the new Sign Code;
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 4-12-12
BM:bjs Page 1 of 13
`9l
NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF TUKWILA,
WASHINGTON, HEREBY ORDAINS AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1. Definition of "Billboard Receiving Areas" Amended. Ordinance No.
2303 §2 (part), as codified in Tukwila Municipal Code (TMC) Chapter 19.08,
"Definitions," is hereby amended to read as follows:
Billboard Receiving Areas are those areas of the City along South 180th Street zoned
as Commercial/Light Industrial; those properties south of South 180th Street along West
Valley Highway zoned as Commercial/Light Industrial; all properties located along
Boeing Access Road; ,a4-those properties along East Marginal Way, north of Boeing
Access Road, and all properties located along Airport Way, north of Boeing Access
Road, for which permits for new billboards may be issued if the criteria of this stef
title are satisfied. Attachments AD and €B, codified in Title 19 as Figures 19-1 and 19-
2 are hereby amended. These maps t show the billboard receiving areas listed with
this definition and are for illustrative purposes only.
Section 2. TMC Section Adopted. A new section is hereby added to TMC
Chapter 19.08, "Definitions," to read as follows:
GBCI means the Green Building Certification Institute or successor entity.
Section 3. TMC Section Adopted. A new section is hereby added to TMC
Chapter 19.08, "Definitions," to read as follows:
Fuel Canopy is a structure designed to provide weather protection to motorists in order
for them to fill vehicles with gasoline, diesel, compressed natural gas, propane,
electricity or other similar compounds that allow for the powering of vehicles. The
following components must be in place beneath the structure in order for this definition
to apply to a structure: 1) There must be at least two fuel dispensing devices; and 2)
Customers must have the ability to pay electronically.
Section 4. TMC Section Adopted. A new section is hereby added to TMC
Chapter 19.08, "Definitions," to read as follows:
LFED means the Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design or successor
program, as administered by the United States Green Building Council or successor
agency.
Section 5. TMC Section 19.12.030, "Exceptions - Sign Permits Not Required,"
Amended. Ordinance No. 2303 §3 (part), as codified at TMC Section 19.12.030, is
hereby amended to read as follows:
The following shall not require issuance of permits by the City. The exception is
only from the need to obtain a permit and shall not be construed as relief from
compliance with other requirements of this title. The provisions of this section shall be
narrowly construed so as to effectuate the purposes of this title, as enumerated in TMC
Section 19.04.020.
WAWord Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 4-12-12
BM:bjs Page 2 of 13
14
1. Repainting of an existing sign when there is no other alteration. This
exception shall not be interpreted to allow the changing of copy or face changes on an
existing sign.
2. Refacing panel change or copy change on existing conforming, monument
signs that have valid Tukwila sign permits as permitted by TMC Sections 19.20.030
(13)(7), 19.20.040 (6), or 19.32.075.
23. Temporary signs and decorations customary for holidays, such as
Independence Day and Thanksgiving, erected on private property. Signs may only
contain non-commercial speech.
34. Temporary window signs, subject to the limitations of TMC Section
19.24.080.
45. Traffic signs and/or markings installed by the City of Tukwila, King County
or Washington State Department of Transportation for the purpose of regulating,
warning or directing traffic. Signs may be installed within the right-of-way or on private
property, with the permission of the property owner. All signs installed under this
exception shall meet the requirements of the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices
for Streets and Highways, current edition, published by the U.S. Department of
Transportation.
56. Signs typically installed on utilities and wireless communication facilities
denoting danger or other safety information, including emergency contact information.
67. Political campaign signs, subject to the limitations of TMC Section
19.24.090.
:78. Temporary signs installed at City parks. All signs shall be approved by the
Tukwila Director of Parks and Recreation and shall meet the requirements of this code.
69. Land use notice boards per TMC Section 18.104.110.
610. Text or graphics on umbrellas located in outdoor seating or plaza
areas
4411. Up to four directional signs per premises where there is a need to
direct vehicular traffic. Freestanding signs may be up to three feet in height and two
square feet per face or a total of four square feet for all faces. Flush -mounted building
signs may be up to three square feet in size.
4412. The following exceptions are specific to properties developed with
residential uses in residential zones:
a. Each residential property shall be permitted one 1.5-square-foot,
building- mounted plaque; and
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 4-12-12
BM:bjs Page 3 of 13
15
b. Each residential property shall be permitted one 6-square-foot banner
or rigid sign that is temporary in nature; and
c. Temporary incidental signs may be displayed with no restrictions from
sunset on a Friday (or the day preceding a designated holiday) until sunset on the
following Sunday (or the Monday following a Sunday if the Monday is a designated
holiday). No individual sign may exceed six square feet in size. It is intended that this
subsection shall apply to garage sale and real estate "open house" signs, however
content of the sign is not restricted.
4-213. Display of up to three flags, each on individual flag poles, per premise.
Content of the flags is not regulated.
Section 6. TMC Section 19.20.030, "Permanent Signs in Residential Zones,"
Amended. Ordinance No. 2303 §5 (part), as codified at TMC Section 19.20.030,
subparagraph B., is hereby amended to read as follows:
B. Monument Sign Design Standards.
1. The area of a monument sign is limited to 30 square feet per sign face and
a total of 60 square feet for all sides. Monument signs located on a premise with at
least one building that is certified as LEED by the GBCI shall be permitted to be 35
square feet per face and a total of 70 square feet for all sides.
2. The sign shall be no taller than five feet.
3. Maximum width of the sign shall not exceed 15 feet.
4. The sign must meet sight distance triangle restrictions.
5. The sign shall be located in a landscaped area.
6. The sign may only use indirect down lighting methods except for dynamic
signs as allowed under TMC 19.20.030 (D). The lighting shall have no spillover impact
on adjacent properties.
7. A monument sign permitted under this section is permitted to complete
refaces, panel changes and copy changes without the need to obtain a new permit,
provided ALL of the following_ criteria are met:
a. The monument sign was authorized bVthe City under a permit issued
on or after August 24, 2010.
b. The property owner, or authorized agent of the property owner, was
the applicant to secure the permit as required under this section.
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 4-12-12
BM:bjs Page 4 of 13
16
c. The reface or copy change does not include any structural changes to
the sign that result in a change of signor message area, modification in sign height,
inclusion of a dynamic sign component, or change in the monument sign's location.
d. Within 30 days of completion of the copy change or reface, the
property owner or authorized agent shall transmit to the City a Notice of Copy Change
Form with a photo of the revised sign face.
Section 7. TMC Section 19.20.040, "Permanent Free -Standing Signage in
Commercial/Industrial Zones," Amended. Ordinance No. 2303 §5 (part), as codified
at TMC Section 19.20.040, is hereby amended to read as follows:
Monument signs are permitted within all commercial and industrial zones, subject to the
following standards:
1. Design Standards. Each premise is permitted to have one free-standing
monument -style sign. Additional monument signs are permitted if the premise contains
over 800 feet of linear frontage on City or quasi -public streets, per Table 1 below.
Table 1 — Design Standards for Permanent Monument
Signs in Commercial and Industrial Zones
Total ROW
of Premise
Allowable Sign
Total Allowable
Maximum
Number of
Message Area
Sign Size
Height
Signs
Less than
36 square feet per
54 square feet per
400 feet
side/72 square
side/108 square
6 feet
One
feet total
feet total
400-599
50 square feet per
70 square feet
feet
side/100 square
per side/140
7 feet
One
feet total
square feet total
600-799
60 square feet per
80 square feet
feet
side/120 square
per side/160
7 feet
One
feet total
square feet total
800-999
66 square feet per
88 square feet
feet
side/132 square
per side/176
8 feet
Two
feet total
square feet total
1,000 feet
72 square feet per
96 square feet
One for every
and over
side/144 square
per side/192
8 feet
400 feet of linear
-feet total
square feet total
street frontage.
a. Allowable sign message area is either the face panel of the sign or, for
channel letters or signs painted on seating or retaining walls, that portion of the sign
devoted to the actual message, logo or business name.
b. Total size is the entire area of the sign, including the support structure.
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 4-12-12
BM:bjs
Page 5 of 13
17
c. Monument signs located on a premise with at least one building that is
certified as LEED by the GBCI shall be permitted to have a sign message area increase
and total size area increase of one percent.
2. Special Comer Properties or Properties with Multiple Street Frontages. A
property that borders on more than one public street, but has less than 800 total feet of
linear frontage, is permitted to have one monument sign per street frontage if the
following criteria are met:
a. The property has at least 200 feet of frontage on each public street
where a sign will be placed,
b. Each public street provides direct access to the property; and
c. For each separate street frontage Table 1 shall be used to determine
the design standards for any proposed monument sign.
3. Setback. All monument signs shall be placed at a minimum of five feet from
all property lines. No sign taller than three feet shall be placed within the sight distance
triangle of an access point, unless it can be demonstrated the sign will not pose a safety
issue by reducing visibility.
4. Maximum Width. The maximum permitted width of a monument sign is 15
feet.
5. Address. In order to facilitate emergency response, all new freestanding
signs shall have the address number or address number range of the premise listed on
the structure. The address shall not be counted toward the allowable sign message
area limit. Address numbers must be plainly legible and visible from the street fronting
the property. These numbers shall contrast with their background. Address numbers
shall be Arabic numerals or alphabet letters. Numbers shall be a minimum of four
inches high with a minimum stroke width of 1.5 inches.
6. A monument sign permitted under this section is permitted to complete
refaces and copy changes without having to obtain a new permit, provided ALL of the
following criteria are met:
a. The monument sign was authorized by the City under a permit issued
on or after August 24, 2010.
b. The property owner, or authorized agent of the property owner, was
the applicant to secure the permit as required by TMC Section 19.20.040 (6)(a).
c. The reface or copy change does not include any structural changes to
the sign that result in a change of sign or message area, modification in sign height
inclusion of a dynamic sign component, or change in the monument sign's location.
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 4-12-12
BM:bjs Page 6 of 13
i;]
d. Within 30 days of completion of the copy change or reface, the
property owner or authorized agent shall transmit to the City a Notice of Copy Change
Form with a photo of the revised sign face.
Section 89. TMC Section 19.20.050, "Permanent Building -Mounted Signs in
Commercial/Industrial Zones," Amended. Ordinance No. 2303 §5 (part), as codified
at TMC Section 19.20.050, subparagraph A., is hereby amended to read as follows:
A. Flush -Mounted Building Signs (Wall Signs).
1. Each separate tenant suite with an exterior public entrance is permitted to
have one flush -mounted building sign per exterior public entrance.
2. Buildings where multiple tenants share a common entrance may have one
flush -mounted building sign per exterior public entrance.
3. Wall signs may only be placed within the section of exposed building face
that qualifies for the placement of the building -mounted sign.
4. The area of the wall sign shall be a percentage of the area of exposed
building face where the sign is proposed to be displayed, as calculated per Table 2.
5. Wall signs may not extend above the top of the parapet or eave of the roof
of the wall on which they are located.
Table 2 — Allowable Message Area for. Permanent Wall
Signs in Commercial and Industrial Zones
Area (LxH) of Exposed Building
Face (EBF) in Square Feet
Permitted Sign Area
0-500
EBF x .05 or 20 square feet
501-1,500
(EBF-500) x .04 + 25 square feet
1,501-3,000
EBF-1,500) x .03 + 65 square feet
3,001-5,000
EBF-3,000 x .02 + 110 square feet
Over 5,000
150 square feet maximum size permitted
1) Anv flush -mounted (wall) sign affixed to a building certified as LEED by the GBCI shall be
permitted an area increase of .5 percent of the permitted sign area from Table 2.
(2) A fuel canopy, as defined in this title, is permitted to install one flush -mounted building sign
(wall sign) on each separate elevation of the fuel canopy structure. The area of the sign
shall not exceed five square feet: illumination of the sign is permitted.
Section 9. TMC Section 19.20.060, "Pole Banners," Amended. Ordinance No.
2303 §5 (part), as codified at TMC Section 19.20.060, is hereby amended to read as
follows:
A. Pole banners are eply--permitted in the Tukwila Urban Center zone and on
properties that contain a Public Recreation Overlay as defined by Title 18 of the Tukwila
Municipal Code.
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 4-12-12
BM:bjs Page 7 of 13
19
B. Pole banners may only be attached to parking lot light poles on private
property.
C. Banners may have periodic changes in copy without submittal for a new sign
permit.
D. The maximum area per banner is 10 square feet, with a limit of 2 banners per
pole.
E. The lower edge of the banner must be at least 12 feet above grade.
F. Annual renewal of the banner permit is required.
Section 10. TMC Section Adopted. A new section is hereby added to TMC
Chapter 19.32, "Master Sign Program," to read as follows:
19.32.075 Copy and Refaces of Monument and Grand Monument Signs Approved
under this Chapter
A monument sign or grand monument sign permitted under this section is permitted to
complete refaces and copy changes without having to obtain a new permit, provided
ALL of the following criteria are met:
1. The monument sign or grand monument sign was authorized by the City
under a permit issued on or after August 24, 2010.
2. The property owner, or authorized agent of the property owner, was the
applicant to secure the permit as required by TMC Section 19.32.075 (1).
3. The reface or copy change does not include any structural changes to the
sign that result in a chanqe of sign or message area, modification in sign height,
inclusion of a dynamic sign component, or change in the monument or grand monument
sign's location.
4. Within 30 days of completion of the copy change or reface, the property
owner or authorized agent shall transmit to the City a Notice of Copy Change Form with
a photo of the revised sign face.
Section 11. 'TMC Secfon 19.36.040, n-Conforming Sign Permits,"
Amended. Or finance No. 03 §10 (part), as odified at TMC Section 19.36.040,
subparagrap B. and C., is ereby amended to ead as follows:
B. N n-Conformin Sign Permits.
1. Eligibility A non-conformin sign permit may be issued only in accordance
with t standards listed in this chapter.
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 4-12-12
BM:bjs .
20
Page 8 of 13
2. Permit Required. A non -conforming sign permit is required for all eligible
non -conforming signs within the City. The sign owner shall obtain the permit within 180
days of notification by the City and for any panel or copy changes allowed during the
grace period.
3. Applications. Applications for a non -conforming sign permit shall contain
the name and address of the sign user, the sign owner and the owner of the property
upon which the sign is located, and. such other pertinent information as the Director may
require to ensure compliance with this chapter. The Director may waive specific
submittal requirements determined to be unnecessary for review of an application.
4. Permit Issuance. Any person submitting an application for a non-
conforming sign permit shall use the forms provided by the Department. The Director
shall issue non -conforming sign permits upon a determination of eligibility. The Director
may require the filing of plans or other pertinent information where such information is
necessary to determine compliance with this chapter. Appeals shall be filed in
accordance with TMC Section 19.12.120.
5. Failure to Respond. It is the sign owner's and/or property owner's
responsibility to return the non -conforming sign permit to the City within the 180 days of
notice as outlined in this section. Failure to respond will constitute a waiver of any
grace period provided to the sign under this chapter, and modifications to the sign will
be controlled by TMC Section 19.36.030.
C. Loss of Legal Non -Conforming Status. Non -conforming signs shall either be
removed or immediately brought into compliance with this chapter upon the occurrence
of one or more of the following events:
days Of RetiGe of non n-nonformanGe.
-21. When an application is submitted to the City for a project that is subject to
design review, any non -conforming building -mounted signs on the premise affected by
the construction and all non -conforming free-standing signs lose their non -conforming
status.
32. When any panel or copy changes are proposed after the expiration of the
grace period.
43. When the sign meets the definition of abandoned.
54. Damage of 25 percent or more in the value of either the non -conforming
sign or the structure to which it is affixed.
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 4-12-12
BM:bjs Page 9 of 13
21
Section 12. TMC Chapter Adopted. TMC Chapter 19.37, "Non -Conforming Signs
in Annexation Areas," is hereby established to read as follows:
CHAPTER 19.37
Non -Conforming Signs in Annexation Areas
Sections:
19.37.010 Purpose
19.37.020 Definition and Removal of Legally Non -Conforming Permanent Signs
19.37.030 Non -Conforming Sign Permits
19.37.040 Non -Conforming Temporary Signs
19.37.050 Additional Signage Prohibited
19.37.010 Purpose
The purpose of this chapter is to establish limits on the use of and requirements for the
removal of non -conforming signs within areas of the City that were annexed after May 1,
2012. Subject to the remaining restrictions of this chapter, non -conforming signs that
were otherwise lawful on the effective date of the annexation may remain subject to the
limitations under this chapter. The provisions of this chapter do not apply to billboards
within annexation areas.
19.37.020 Definition and Removal of Legally Non -Conforming Permanent Signs
A. All permanent signs within annexation areas are considered legally non-
conforming if the siqn was erected in conformance with a valid permit, if a permit was
required, and complied with all applicable laws at the time of the sign's installation.
Non -conforming rights are not granted to temporary signs or signs that were in violation
of King County ordinances or regulations of the State of Washington. The burden of
establishing that a sign is non -conforming lies solely with the individual asserting the
claim that a sign is non -conforming.
B. Any monument sign installed within an annexation area that exceeds Sign
Code standards as to sign area, height or setback by 15 percent or less shall be
deemed a conforming sign.
C. Grace Period for Permanent Signs in Annexation Areas. Siqns that were
installed within the annexation area prior to the effective date of the City's annexation
and became non -conforming upon annexation in the City, may be issued a non-
conforming sign permit that will allow the signs to remain for 10 years from the effective
date of the annexation. This 10-year period shall be known as the "annexation grace
period.".
D. Sign Modifications During the Annexation Grace Period. During the annexation
grace period, signs with non -conforming sign permits may be refaced and the panel or
copy changed, provided the area, height and location of the sign remain unchanged. A
non-conformina sian hermit will be issued for work covered under this section.
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 4-12-12
BM:bjs Page 10 of 13
22
Permanent signs and sign structures that are moved replaced or structurally altered
must be brought into conformance with the current Sign Code regulations.
_ E. Sign Modifications After the Annexation Grace Period. After the annexation
grace period the sign is permitted to remain as -is indefinitely. However, relocation, re -
erection alteration replacement or change in any way to a legal, non -conforming sign,
including the structure or sign panel/face/copy, will require the sign be brought into
compliance with the sign code in effect at the time of submittal of a complete sign permit
application.
19.37.030 Non -Conforming Sign Permits
A. Non -Conforming Sign Inventory. The Director shall, as soon as practicable
after the effective date of the annexation, survey the annexation area for signs that do
not conform to the requirements of Title 19. Upon determination that a sign is non-
conforming or illegal, the Director shall use reasonable efforts to notify the sign owner,
in writing and, where practicable, the owner of the property on which the sign is located.
Notification shall include:
1. Whether the siqn is non -conforming or illegal.
2. Whether the sign may be eligible for anon -conforming sign permit. If the
identity of the sign owner cannot be determined after reasonable inquiry, the notice may
be affixed in a conspicuous place on the sign or on the business premises with which
the sign is associated. The failure of the City to identify the sign owner shall not relieve
the property owner from the requirements of this section.
B. Non -Conforming Sign Permits.
1. Eligibility. A non -conforming sign permit may be issued only in accordance
with the standards listed in this chapter.
2. Permit Required. A non -conforming sign permit is required for all eligible
non -conforming signs within the annexation areas. The sign owner shall obtain the
permit within 180 days of notification by the City. Sign permits shall be obtained for any
panel or copV change allowed during the annexation grace period. There is no permit
fee for the issuance of the non -conforming sign permit.
3. Applications. Applications for a non -conforming sign permit shall contain
the name and address of the sign user, the sign owner and the owner of the property
upon which the sign is located, and such other pertinent information as the Director may
require to ensure compliance with this chapter. The Director may waive specific
submittal requirements determined to be unnecessary for review of an application.
4. Failure to Respond. It is the sign owner and/or property owner's responsibility
to return the non -conforming sign permit to the City within the 180 days of notice as
outlined in this section. Failure to respond will constitute a waiver of any grace period
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 4-12-12
BM:bjs Page 11 of 13
23
provided to the sign under this chapter and modifications to the sign will be controlled by
TMC Section 19.36.030.
5. Permit Issuance. Any person submitting an application for a non-
conforming sign permit shall use the forms provided by the Department. The Director
shall issue non -conforming sign permits upon a determination of eligibility. The Director
may require the filing of .plans or other pertinent information where such information is
necessary to determine compliance with this chapter. Appeals shall be filed in
accordance with TMC Section 19.12.120.
C. Loss of Legal Non -conforming Status. Non -conforming signs shall be brought
into compliance with this chapter upon the occurrence of one or more of the following
events:
1. When an application is submitted to the City for a project that is subject to
design review, any non -conforming building -mounted signs on the premise affected by
the construction and all non -conforming free-standing signs lose their non -conforming
status.
2. When any panel or copy changes are proposed after the expiration of the
annexation grace period.
3. When the sign meets the definition of abandoned.
4. Damage of 25 percent or more in the value of either the non -conforming
sign or the structure to which it is affixed.
D. Maintenance. Ordinary maintenance and repair of a sign shall be permitted
without loss of non -conforming status if the cost of all maintenance and repair over a
two-year period is less than 25 percent of the cost of replacing the sign.
19.37.040 Non -Conforming Temporary Signs
A. Non -conforming temporary signs in annexation areas must be removed within
120 days of the effective date of the annexation.
B. Commercial real estate signs in existence in the annexation area prior to the
adoption of this code are permitted to remain for up to three months, after which time
the signs must be removed and any future signage must comply with the terms of this
code.
19.37.050 Additional Signage Prohibited
No additional permanent building -mounted signaqe is permitted on a tenant space that
contains a non -conforming sign. No additional permanent freestanding signs are
permitted on a premises that contains a non -conforming freestanding sign.
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 4-12-12
BM:bjs Page 12 of 13
24
Section 13. Corrections by City Clerk or Code Reviser. Upon approval of the
City Attorney, the City Clerk and the code reviser are authorized to make necessary
corrections to the ordinance, including correction of clerical errors; references to other
local, state or federal laws, codes rules, or regulations; or ordinance numbering and
section/subsection numbering.
Section 14. Severability. If any section, subsection, paragraph, sentence, clause
or phrase of this ordinance or its application to any person or situation should be held to
be invalid or unconstitutional for any reason by a court of competent jurisdiction, such
invalidity or unconstitutionality shall not affect the validity or constitutionality of the
remaining portions of this ordinance or its application to any other person or situation.
Section 15. Effective Date. This ordinance or a summary thereof shall be
published in the official newspaper of the City, and shall take effect and be in full force
five days after passage and publication as provided by law.
PASSED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF TUKWILA, WASHINGTON, at
a Regular Meeting thereof this day of , 2012.
ATTEST/AUTHENTICATED:
Christy O'Flaherty, MMC, City Clerk
APPROVED AS TO FORM BY:
Office of the City Attorney
Jim Haggerton, Mayor
Filed with the City Clerk:_
Passed by the City Council:
Published:
Effective Date:
Ordinance Number:
Attachments: A - Map of Billboard Receiving Area (West Valley Hwy.)
B - Map of Billboard Receiving Area (Boeing Access Road and
East Marginal Way South)
W:\Word Processing\Ordinances\Sign Code update 4-12-12
BM:bjs
Page 13 of 13
25
5
For Illustrative Purposes Only Attachment B
itk
Dr
a,
City of Tukwila
Billboard
Receiving
Area -
N
DRAFT
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
TUKWILA, WASHINGTON, REVISING THE LAND USE FEE
SCHEDULE TO AMEND FEES RELATED TO CERTAIN TYPES
OF SIGNAGE, AND AMENDING RESOLUTION NO. 1722.
WHEREAS, on August 16, 2010, the City Council of the City of Tukwila adopted
Resolution No. 1722, which established a new fee schedule for land use,
environmental, and sign permit applications; and
WHEREAS, the City Council desires to encourage applicants to submit plans
electronically in order to facilitate the efficient review of sign permits; and
WHEREAS, the City Council wishes to update the fee schedule periodically to
respond to changing business conditions;
NOW THEREFORE THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF TUKWILA,
WASHINGTON, HEREBY RESOLVES AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1. Resolution No. 1722 is hereby amended as follows to include the
following sign permit application fees:
Permit Type
2012 Feel
Retainer
Plus any review
hours over
retainer (2)
Appeal - Zoning, Sign, SEPA, Subdivision Code (P-Appeal) r►
$541
+ hours over 5
Binding Site Improvement Plan (TMC Chapter 17.16 P-BSIP
$3,497
Boundary Line Adjustment P-BLA/LC
$1,536
Zoning Code and Sign Code Interpretation
TMC Sections 18.96.020 and 19.12.160
$319
Comprehensive Plan Amendment (TMC Chapter 18.80) (P-CPA)
$4,153
+ hours over40
Conditional Use Permit (P-CUP), Shoreline CUP (1)
$3,554
Design Review (TMC Section 18.60.030 P-DR
Administrative
$2,048
Public Hearing
$3,670
Major Modification
$1,255
Minor Modification
$570
W:\Word Processing\Resolutions\Land Use Fee Schedule amended 4-12-12
BM:bjs Page 1 of 4
29
Permit Type
2012 Feel
Retainer
Plus any review
hours over
retainer (2)
Lot Consolidation P-BLA/LC
$570
Noise Variance TMC Chapter 8.22
Type 1
$444
Type II
$599
Type III (1)
$1,332
Planned Residential Development
Administrative TMC Section 18.46.110 P-APRD
$1,990
Public Hearin TMC Section 18.46.110 P-PRD
$5,119
+ hours over 50
Minor Modification TMC Section 18.46.130
$541
Major Modification TMC Section 18.46.130
$2,221
Rezone - Map Change TMC Chapter 18.84 P-R
$3,670
+ hours over 35
Reasonable Use Exception to SAO TMC Section 18.45.180 (1)
$3,071
+ hours over 30
Sensitive Area Master Plan Overlay
TMC Section 18.45.160 P-SAMP
$5,119
+ hours over 50
SEPA Environmental Review TMC Trtle 21 P-SEPA
SEPA Planned Action (P-PACT)
$541
SEPA Checklist
$1,565
SEPA EIS Fee
$3,187
+ hours over 30
SEPA Addendum
$541
Shoreline Environment Re -designation (P-Shore D
$3,670
+ hours over 30
Shoreline Permit Exemption TMC Chapter 18.44
$222
Shoreline Substantial Development Permit (TMC Chapter 18.44)
P-Shore
Project Value $5,000-10,000
$1,082
$10,001 - 50,000
$2,531
+ hours over 25
$50,001 - 500,000
$4,037
+ hours over 40
More than $500,000
$5,119
+ hours over 50
Signs TMC Title 19
Temporary Sign Permit P-T sin TMC Section 19.24.040
$97
Special Event Si na e TMC Section 19.24.060
$97
Permanent Sin Permit P-P sin TMC Chapter 19.20
$222 Qj
Master Sin Program Administration
$1,990
Master Sin Program BAR
$3,187
Pole Sign Banners Initial Application TMC Section 19.20.060
$22-2 97
Pole Sign Banner Annual Renewal TMC Section 19.20.060
W 50
Opt Out, Tukwila Urban Center TMC Section 19.22.050
$222
Non -Conforming Sin Permit TMC Section 19.36.040
$0
New Billboard (TMC 19.38.040) or refurbished Billboard
TMC Section 19.38.050
$541
Special Permission P-SP
Caro Container TMC Section 18.50.060
$541
Landscape Perimeter Averaging TMC Section 18.52.020
$541
Parking Standard for Use Not Specified
TMC Section 18.56.100
$541
+ hours over 5
Parking Variance, Modification or Waiver
TMC Sections 18.56.130 and 18.56.140 (1)
$888
+ hours over 8
W:\Word Processing\Resolutions\Land Use Fee Schedule amended 4-12-12
BM:bjs Page 2 of 4
30
Permit Type__
2012 Feel
Retainer
Plus any review
hours over
retainer (2)
Parking Lot Re-striin
$541
Residential Parking Reduction (TMC Section 18.56.065
$541
Shared, Covenant and Complementary Parking Reduction
TMC Section 18.56.070
$541
+ hours over 5
Sensitive Area Deviation, Buffer Reduction (TMC Chapter 18.45
$1,507
+ hours over 15
Single Family Design Standard Exception
TMC Section 18.50.055
$541
TSO Special Permission Use (TMC Section 18.41.060 (1)
$888
Short Plat (TMC Chapter 17.12 P-SS
2-4 Lots
$3,497
5-9 Lots
$3,980
Subdivision Preliminary Approval (TMC Chapter 17.14)
P-SUBP (1)
$5,119
+ hours over 50
Subdivision Final Approval P-SUBP
$3,187
+ hours over 30
Tree Clearing Permit and Exception (TMC Chapter 18.54) (P-Tree)
$53
+ hours over 2
Unclassified Use Permit (TMC Chapter 18.66 P-UU
$5,119
+ hours over 50
Variance - Zoning, Sign, Shoreline (P-VAR) (1)
$2,588
Wireless Communication Facility TMC Chapter 18.58 P-Wire
Minor
$541
Administrative
$1,536
Major or Height Waiver Ill
$3,071
Zoning Code Text Amendment (TMC Chapter 18.80) (P-Code)
$4,153
(1) All Hearing Examiner costs will be passed through to the applicant.
(2) The application fee covers the specified number of review hours. Hours over this retainer will be
charged at $92.00 per hour.
(3) The fee for a Permanent Sign Permit (TMC Chapter 19.20) shall be reduced by $50 for a sign
permit application submitted utilizing the City's electronic plan submittal process.
Fee Type
2012 Feel
Retainer
Plus any review
hours over
retainer
Annexation (P-Annex)
$5,408
Development Agreement (P-DA) `
$1,990
+ hours over 20
Legal Lot Verification
$512
Mailing Label Fee for City to generate labels
$420
Pre -Application Meeting (PREAPP)
$444
Public Notice Mailing Fee
$1 per address, per mailing
Zoning Verification Letter
$319
* The application fee covers the specified number of review hours. Hours over this
retainer will be charged at $92.00 per hour.
W:\Word Processing\Resolutions\Land Use Fee Schedule amended 4-12-12
BM:bjs Page 3 of 4
31
PASSED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF TUKWILA, WASHINGTON, at
a Regular Meeting thereof this day of , 2012.
ATTEST/AUTHENTICATED:
Christy O'Flaherty, MMC, City Clerk Verna Seal, Council President
APPROVED AS TO FORM BY:
Filed with the City Clerk:_
Passed by the City Council:
Resolution Number:
Shelley M. Kerslake, City Attorney
WAWord Processing\ResolutionsIand Use Fee Schedule amended 4-12-12
BM:bjs Page 4 of 4
32
City of Tukwila
Jim Haggerton, Mayor
INFORMATIONAL MEMORANDUM
TO: Mayor Haggerton
Community Affairs and Parks Committee
FROM: Brandon J. Miles, Senior Planner
DATE: March 19, 2012
SUBJECT: Amendments to Title 19, "Sign Code"
ISSUE
The purpose of tonight's meeting is for Community Affairs and Parks to provide the Department
of Community Development direction on possible changes to Title 19 of the Tukwila Municipal
Code ("TMC"), commonly referred to as the "Sign Code."
BACKGROUND/DISCUSSION
On February 6, 2012, a presentation was made to the City Council regarding the new sign code,
which was adopted in August of 2010. The purpose of the presentation was to provide the City
Council an overview of how the sign code has been received by the community as well as to
initiate the process to make minor amendments to the Sign Code.
Attachment "A" to this staff report is a matrix that outlines those areas of the Sign Code that staff
believes changes are needed. Some of the changes are simply fixing of typos in the original
sign code; other changes require that the City Council provide staff policy direction in order to
address the specific item.
The matrix has been numbered 1-9. The numbers listed below correspond with the matrix
numbers.
Minor Code Amendments- Policy Direction Needed
1. Commercial Signage on Fuel Canopies
The sign code does not allow signage on fuel canopies. This was an oversight in drafting the
sign code and staff recommends amending the sign code to allow a small wall sign on fuel
canopies. The previous sign code allowed one wall sign on a fuel canopy, up to 20% of the
exposed building face.' While 20% of the exposed building face may seem large, in reality, the
small area of the exposed building face of the canopy structure severely limits the size of the
wall sign. In most cases the wall signs installed under the previous sign code ranged in area
between four and eight square feet.
1 TMC 19.32.160 (2)
33
INFORMATIONAL MEMO
Page 2
Staff Recommendation
Staff recommends that service stations be permitted to install one flush mounted building wall
per elevation on fuel canopies. The sign can be illuminated, with a maximum size of five square
feet.
2. Streamline Permit Process for Conforming Freestanding Signs.
The Sign Code requires that a permit be obtained for any reface or copy change to an existing
freestanding sign. However, the code requirement is burdensome to owners of freestanding
signs that comply with the City's sign code.
Staff Recommendation
Staff would like to allow refaces and copy changes to freestanding signs that meet the current
code to be accomplished without having to obtain a new permit. Thus, a property owner would
only have to obtain a permit once.
3. Electronic Plan Submittal
Many cities are moving to electronic plan submittals for all types of permits. Electronic plan
submittal allows for permits to be submitted via email with fees paid using credit cards. Review
of plans submitted electronically is also done electronically, essentially the process is "paper
free." DCD is hoping to start accepting permits electronically when the City switches to a new
permit system in 2013. Electronic submittal of sign permits is a logical first step in moving the
entire City to electronic plan submittal. Sign permits are fairly straight forward and have a very
basic review process. Staff would like to encourage contractors to move to electronic plan
submittal by reducing the permit fee for those contractors who take advantage of the system.
34 ZADCD n Clerk'slBrandonffverton DAICAP, 2012.03.26\2012 Memo - for merge.doc
INFORMATIONAL MEMO
Page 3
Staff Recommendation
Staff recommends that the permit fee for sign permits submitted electronically be reduced by
$50.
4. Annexation Areas
The City has two remaining potential annexation areas. Upon annexation, the City will have to
address a range of issues related to non -conformities, including non -conforming signs. Staff
would like to be proactive in this area by adopting code language that will specify the regulation
of non -conforming signs in certain areas upon annexation.
In order to reduce the impact of the new sign code, the City provided a grace period for signs
that met the provisions of the old sign code, but became non -conforming with the adoption of
the new sign code. For example, freestanding signs that became non -conforming were
provided a ten year grace period before they were required to come into compliance with the
current sign code regulation. The grace period ends in August of 2010. Under the grace period,
freestanding signs can be refaced and copy change, with a permit, provided there are no
structural alternations to the sign. Staff believes a similar concept can be employed for
annexation areas.
ZADCD n Clerles\BrandonlRiverton DAICAP, 2012.03.26\2012 Memo - for merge.doe 35
INFORMATIONAL MEMO
Page 4
North Annexation areas, which includes signage which may become
non -conforming upon annexation to the City.
36 Z:IDCD n ClerWs1&andori R verton DAICAP, 2012.03.26\2012 Memo - for merge.doe
INFORMATIONAL MEMO
Page 5
Staff Recommendation
Provide signs in annexation areas with a ten year grace period, which would start on the
effective date of the annexation. Signs may be refaced and receive copy changes, with a permit,
during the grace period.
5. Add Airport Way as a Billboard Receiving Area
In order to encourage the removal of billboards within the City, the City Council established two
"billboard receiving areas". The purpose of these billboard receiving areas is to provide
locations for new billboards, provided a set number of billboards are removed within "designated
sending areas." TMC 19.08.067 establishes the following two billboard receiving areas:
a. The southern billboard receiving area includes all of West Valley Highway, south of S.
180th Street and all of S. 180th Street east of West Valley Highway.
b. The northern billboard receiving areas includes all properties along East Marginal Way,
north of Boeing Access Road and all properties along Boeing Access Road.
Establishment of the billboard receiving areas was an attempt to to balance areas of the City
where the Council would accept billboard structures, while at the same time establishing areas
in which billboard companies would be willing to locate. The receiving areas are generally
heavy and light industrial areas, which are distant from the urban core and residential areas.
The sending areas are all areas of the City that are not designed as billboard receiving areas
zones (TMC 19.08.069).
An applicant must secure the removal of existing billboards in order to install a new billboard in
one of the two designed receiving areas. Billboards that are to be removed must be located in
sending areas. TMC 19.38 provides a specific formula, which requires that the applicant
remove more billboards within the sending areas than is proposed to be installed. To provide
an example of this code at work: a new billboard has been approved to be constructed at the
southeast corner of West Valley Highway and S. 180th Street. The proposed billboard will have
one face and pursuant to TMC 19.38.040 the applicant is required to secure the removal of
three billboard faces. Given that the r billboard must be removed within the designed "sending
area," the applicant has proposed to remove two billboard structures along Tukwila International
Boulevard and one along East Marginal Way.
In administering the billboard code staff realized that Airport Way was not included as a
billboard receiving area and thus, by definition, is a billboard sending area. The properties along
Airport Way have the same land use as those along East Marginal Way. The primary reason to
include Airport Way as a billboard receiving zone is so billboard companies do not propose to
remove existing billboards along Airport Way in order to get credit for new billboard construction.
In staff's opinion, the City should focus on billboard removal within the core of Tukwila
International Blvd and near residential zones.
Staff Recommendation
Include Airport Way as a billboard receiving area.
6. Pole Banners fee and Expansion of Allowable Zones
The Sign Code allows for the display of banners on lights poles within parking lights within the
Tukwila Urban Center (TUC). The purpose of allowing these banners was to encourage a
festive style of signage at commercial developments. Unfortunately, no property owner has
ZADCD n C1eWs\8randon\Riverton DAICAP, 2012.03.26\2012 Memo -for merge.doc 37
INFORMATIONAL MEMO
Page 6
taken advantage of the ability to install these banners. In talking with property owners it seems
that the permit fee of $222 for the installation is a deterrent.
The banners are also only permitted for commercial properties in the TUC zone. With Tukwila
Village moving forward staff thinks it would be useful to allow properties in the Neighborhood
Commercial Center (NCC) to be able to install pole banners. This would allow the Tukwila
Village site and other properties along TIB to install flag pole banners.
Staff Recommendation
Reduce the permit fee for pole banner applications to $25 for the initial application and $15 for
the renewal; allow pole banners to be displayed in the NCC zone.
7. LEED and Built Green Certification
The City of Tukwila has very few incentives for encouraging the construction of LEED and Built
Green Buildings. The sign code provides an avenue for rewarding development in the City that
is built to reduce its environmental impacts. Recently, Starbucks built the City's first LEED
certified building on East Marginal Way South. As part of this review process, staff learned that
often times the LEED process requires that educational signage be installed to provide
education to users of the site. Staff would suggest a nominal bonus be permitted for LEED and
Built Green Certified Buildings.
Staff Recommendation
Staff proposes that structures that are certified as LEED or Built Green be permitted to have a
one percent increase in sign area for any allowed freestanding sign and a .5% area increase for
all permitted wall signs.
Housino Keepina
Staff recommends that the following housekeeping items be amended in the Sign Code.
8. Add notes on Billboard Receiving Maps (Exhibit A and B of Code)
Some confusion exists between the maps (Exhibits A and B of the Sign Code) and the specific
code language regarding which areas of the City are designated as billboard receiving areas.
The maps inadvertently left off some areas of the City that were specifically called out in the
Code language. Staff has applied the specific code language; however, staff would like to
provide a note on exhibits A and B which would clarify the issue.
9. Correct scriber's error in TMC 19.20.050 (4)
A scriber's error at TMC 19.20.050 (F)(4)(b) needs to be fixed. Subsection 5 should actually be
subsection "c". This not a policy change, but simply fixes an error in the original Ordinance.
38 ZADCD n ClerlfslBrandonlRiverton DAICAP, 2012.03.20012 Memo - for merge.doc
INFORMATIONAL MEMO
Page 7
RECOMMENDATION
The goal of this evening's meeting is for the Committee to provide policy direction on the
proposed amendments to Title 19 outlined above. The Committee can also ask staff to examine
any other amendments to Title 19 that it feels are needed. Based on the outcome of tonight's
meeting, staff will come back to the Committee on April 9, 2012 that represents the
recommendation of the Committee. Staff anticipated a public hearing to be held on April 23,
2012, with possible Council action on May 7, 2012.
ATTACHMENTS
A. Matrix of Proposed Sign Code Updates
ZADCD n Clerk'sl8randoriNverton DXCAP, 2012.03.2W012 Memo -for merge.doc 39
Title 19 Sign Code Amendments, CAP Meeting, March 26, 2012 Attachment A
#
Topic
Suggested Policy
Impact on business and
Other Considerations
property owners?
1.
Commercial Signage on Fuel Canopies
Allow fuel canopies to have
Would increase the
None
signs under specific
allowable signage for service
The existing code has no provisions for the
limitations.
stations.
placement of signage on fuel canopies at service
stations. Such signage is common place and
usually is the primary signage for gas stations.
2.
Streamline Permit Process for Conforming
Streamline the permit
Copy changes to existing
There will be a slight
Freestanding Signs.
process for freestanding signs
freestanding signs that meet
reduction in the sign permit
that meeting code.
code will not require a sign
fees generated by the City.
Currently, the City requires a permit to reface a
permit which will save
However, fees are used to
freestanding sign that meets code.
Tukwila businesses and
offset City time in reviewing
property owners time and
sign permit applications and
money.
not a revenue generating
source.
3.
Electronic Plan Submittal
Electronic plan submittal
Reduces permit fees for
Staff is currently working to
saves time and money for the
businesses, property
implement electronic plan
Reduce the fee paid by applicants who take
City and applicant as well as
owners, and contractors.
submittal. The fee
advantage of electronic plan submittal.
reducing greenhouse gases
reduction will not take place
by reducing contractors' trips
until the system is up and
to City Hall. Providing a
running.
financial incentive would
encourage people to use the
program. Staff is proposing
$50 reduction in permit fees
for each permanent sign that
is submitted electronically.
4.
Annexation Areas
When the City adopted the
No impact to current
None
previous sign code, signs that
Tukwila property owners or
The potential north annexation area includes
met the provision of the old
businesses. Business and
many existing signs. The City is working to
sign code but were made
property owners within
N
#
Topic
Suggested Policy
Impact on business and
property owners?
Other Considerations
complete the annexation and once the annexation
non -conforming were
annexation areas will
is complete, the City will have to address many
provided specific grace
eventually have to bring
non -conforming issues, including non -conforming
periods. The length of the
signs in compliance. By
signs.
grace period was dependent
adopting this policy before
on whether the sign was a
the City completes any
freestanding sign or a
annexations it provides clear
freeway interchange sign.
direction to property owners
Staff suggests that a similar
and businesses on what to
approach be used for
expect after annexation.
annexation areas. Any legally
The policy also creates a
installed signs in an
level playing field for
annexation area may remain
existing businesses and
and have unlimited refaces
property owners in the city
for up to ten years from the
and those that may
effective date of the
eventually be annexed into
annexation. Once the ten
the City.
year period has expired the
sign may remain, but any
reface or copy change would
require conformance to the
City's sign code.
5.
Add Airport Way to Billboard Receiving Area.
Designate Airport Way as a
Would allow properties
The code change is needed
billboard receiving zone. Staff
along Airport Way to be
to reflect the City's policy
The sign code provides both a map and a
suggestion would be that all
eligible for new billboards or
priorities for billboard
definition of which areas of the City are eligible for
properties north of Boeing
conversion of existing
removal in in residential and
new billboards. During original designation of the
access road and east of
billboards into digital
neighborhood commercial
billboard receiving area Airport Way was not
Interstate 5 be considered as
billboards.
areas such as the core of
included as being eligible for new billboards. By
a Billboard Receiving Zone.
Tukwila International Blvd.
not including the area as a billboard receiving
Airport Way South is heavy
area, it allows billboards from the area to be
industrial and therefore
removed and counted towards the credit to
more appropriate as a
installing new billboards. There are other more
receiving rather than
#
Topic
Suggested Policy
Impact on business and
Other Considerations
property owners?
pressing areas of the City where the City wants to
sending location for
see billboards removed.
billboards.
6.
Pole Banners
1. Reduce the permit
1. Reduces permit fees
None
fee for pole banners
for applicants which
The sign code allows pole banners on private light
from $222 to $25.
will hopefully
poles in the TUC. A permit is required to install
Renewal of the
encourage property
the banners. No property owners have taken
permit will only cost
owners to install
advantage of the allowable banners. Staffs
$15.
decorative banners.
conversations with property owners had indicating
2. Allow pole banners
2. Would expand the
that the permit fee discourages the banner
on private light
use of light pole
installation.
standards in the NCC
banners to
zones.
properties zoned
NCC zones, such as the Tukwila Village site, are not
NCC, including the
permitted to have pole banners. Staff would like
Tukwila Village site.
to encourage these banners in the NCC.
7.
LEED and Built Green Certification
Reward property owners that
Provides a benefit to
None.
obtain LEED and Built Green
property owners that invest
certification for their
in energy and environmental
investments. Allow a small
upgrades to new and
1% size increase for
existing buildings.
freestanding signs and a .5%
increase for all flush mounted
signs.
S.
Add notes on Billboard Receiving Maps (Exhibit A
Clarify that the maps are
No impact.
None.
and B of Code)
reference only, but that the
specific code language
governs.
9.
Correct scribner's error in TMC 19.20.050 (4)
Not a policy change.
No change from current sign
N/A
code.
c,�
City of Tukwila
• Community Affairs and Parks Committee
COMMUNITY AFFAIRS AND PARKS COMMITTEE
Meeting Minutes
March 26, 2012 — 5: 00 p. m.
PRESENT
Councilmembers: Kathy Hougardy, Chair; Joe Duffie and Allan Ekberg
Staff: Nora Gierloff, Derek Speck, David Cline, Rick Still, Dave Johnson, Peggy McCarthy, Brandon
Miles and Kimberly Matej
Guests: Chuck Parrish, resident
CALL TO ORDER: Committee Chair Hougardy called the meeting to order at 5:01 p.m.
I. PRESENTATIONS
No presentations.
II. BUSINESS AGENDA
A. Sign Code Revisions
Staff is seeking Committee direction regarding several suggested policy changes to the current Sign Code
which was adopted by the Council in August 2010. The Sign Code has been in existence for over a year and
i< staff has had the opportunity to identify areas of the Code which need clarification, simplification or basic
housekeeping such as typographical errors. The suggested amendments are outlined below followed by
Committee direction in bold, if appropriate.
• Allow for signage on fuel canopies. This was inadvertently left out of the current code. The
Committee commented that they would like staff to define fuel canopy.
• In regards to freestanding signs that comply with the City's Sign Code, if there is going to be a reface
or copy change to an existing sign currently in compliance, a second permit will not need to be
secured.
• Reduce sign permit fee by $50 for applications submitted electronically. Permit cost is currently
$222.
• Provide annexation areas with the same 10-year grace period afforded in the current Sign Code when
and if the areas are annexed. The grace period would commence on the effective date of the
annexation.
• Expand the north billboard receiving areas to include Airport Way.
• Add Airport Way as a third billboard receiving area in the City.
• Reduce the sign permit fee for pole banners on private property from $222 to an initial application fee
of $25 and a $15 renewal. Additionally, allow pole banners in the Neighborhood Commercial Center.
Committee Members are interested in the pole banner fee reflecting an amount more in line
with other fees (such as the temporary sign permit fee).
• Recognizing that many LEED and/or Green Built buildings require educational language on the
property to explain the site/building significance, such buildings will be permitted a 1% increase for
free standing signs and a 0.5% increase for permitted wall signs.
Staff will make the appropriate changes and return to Committee on April 9 for review and recommendation
to full Council. Committee Member Ekberg expressed interest in allowing digital and animated displays in the
City to modernize and increase the effectiveness of information sharing. RETURN TO COMMITTEE ON
APRIL 9 WITH RECOMMENDED CHANGES AND DRAFT ORDINANCEMESOLUTION.
45