HomeMy WebLinkAboutFSC 2024-03-05 MinutesTukwila Financial Sustainability Committee
Meeting #5 Summary Notes
March 5, 2024 1 6:00-8:00pm I Tukwila Community Center
Attendees
Committee Members
■ Arta Baharmast, General Manager,
Westfield Southcenter
■ Phillip Combs, COO, Segale Properties
■ Jacob Halverson, Resident
■ Kathy Hougardy, Resident
■ Annie McGrath, CEO, Seattle Southside
Chamber
■ Krysteena Mann, Resident
■ Karin Masters, Resident
City Staff
■ Vicky Carlsen, Finance Director
■ Laurel Humphrey, Council Legislative Analyst
■ Pete Mayer, Parks and Recreation Director
■ Derek Speck, Economic Development Administrator
■ Marty Wine, Acting City Administrator
Consulting Team
■ Katherine Goetz, BERK Consulting
■ Brian Murphy, BERK Consulting
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Peggy McCarthy, Resident
Amber Meza, Resident
Abdiwali Mohamed, Owner, Abdiwali
Mohamed CPA
Diane Myers, Resident
David Puki, Resident
Verna Seal, Resident
Greg Sherlock, Resident
1
Meeting Recap
Welcome and Meeting 4 Recap
Brian Murphy welcomed Committee members and provided an overview of the agenda. Katherine Goetz
provided a brief recap of the material covered and discussions in meeting 4.
Background and Context
Katherine shared information about the City's service level adjustments and staffing over the past several
years, as well as staff compensation. This information was presented in response to questions or items of
discussions at prior Committee meetings.
■ There was a question about the chart showing the cumulative growth in the City's population and FTE
count.
▪ The population data is from the WA Office of Financial Management. The FTE data is from the
City's 2023-2024 Biennial Budget document.
▪ While the information presented was correct, the chart was difficult to read. An email was sent to
all Committee members in follow-up to the meeting with the following data table showing the ratio
of City FTEs per 1,000 residents.
Tukwila Total City FTEs FTEs per 1,000
Year Population without Fire residents
2016 19,803 281 14.2
2017 19,961 280 14.0
2018 20,159 280 13.9
2019 21,292 280 13.2
2020 21,798 280 12.9
2021 22,000 276 12.6
2022 22,620 276 12.2
2023 22,780 294 12.9
Financial rorecasts Overview
Katherine shared an overview of the City's General Fund financial plan and a draft financial plan
incorporating some funding for strategic investments based on prior Committee discussions. This version of
the financial plan will be updated to incorporate the Committee's final recommendations.
• There was a question about the planed use of property tax capacity in the financial plan and
interest in looking at a model where this is not used.
Ei BERK and City staff will prepare this information for the next meeting. City staff will estimate the
changes in service level needed to accommodate this difference in revenue.
• There was a question about how long positions will be funded with ARPA money.
▪ ARPA funding runs through the end of 2024.
• ill City of Tukwila Financial Sustainability Plan I Committee Meeting #5 Summary Notes
2
Draft Committee Guidance Discussion
Brian introduced the draft Committee guidance, which incorporates ideas raised in prior Committee
discussions, email input received from individual members, and staff and consultant recommendations.
Committee members reviewed the structure and individual recommendations and provided suggestions.
These suggestions were generally agreed upon by all Committee members and the consultant team will
revise the document to incorporate these suggestions. The final meeting will focus on reviewing this
revised document.
Meeting Close
Each Committee member shared closing thoughts at the end of the meeting.
■ It is good to stay at a high level and out of the weeds. Everyone cares a lot, but we need to keep
recommendations at a high level. The Committee needs to do a good job presenting information to
the Council so the Council understands the Committee's perspective.
■ Appreciation for the draft report and the comments during the meeting.
• The Committee should consider providing more specifics for the recommendations or including some
broad ideas of policies to consider.
• It is great that the Committee has ended up with this document. It is important to stick to guiding
principles and produce something timeless to guide future councils, rather than something too specific
and timebound. There could be an implementation section for some next steps. The Committee
members should participate in ongoing policy discussions.
• The draft recommendations represent a lot of great ideas. Hopefully the final report gets
recognized for the value it brings.
• The quality of the process has been good — members' voices are being heard and the document
accurately represents Committee input. Recommend talking about access to Council next time.
• Appreciation for everyone's ideas. Having detail will be helpful because individuals can interpret
broad ideas in different ways.
• The document is great and easy to read. The overall process was confusing at first but has gotten
clearer over time. Appreciation for the discussions.
• Recommend using more impactful language. It would be great to see topline messages from the plan
in the news.
• Recommend using more directional language. The report may say "look at something," but should
also recommend a direction forward. The report should emphasize proactive, long-sighted growth
planning.
At the next meeting, the consulting team will share the revised recommendations, present the revised
financial forecast model, and lead a discussion of the estimated tax impact on residences and businesses.
The last meeting will be held on Tuesday, April 2, from 6:00-8:00 pm at the Tukwila Community Center.
• ill City of Tukwila Financial Sustainability Plan I Committee Meeting #5 Summary Notes
3